[badges] [fedora-badges] #112: Koji Build Failure Badges are "Negative"

[fedora-badges]

#112: Koji Build Failure Badges are "Negative"
-------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
               Reporter:  ralph      |                              Owner:
                   Type:  Bug        |                             Status:
  report                             |  closed
               Priority:  minor      |                         Resolution:
               Keywords:             |  pushed
  koji,negative                      |                         Has a name:
      Has a description:  0          |  0
         Artwork status:  None       |  Concept approved (reviewers only):
  External requirements:             |  0
Triaged (triagers only):  1          |            Badge definition status:
                                     |  None
                                     |                   Manually awarded:
                                     |  0
-------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Changes (by ralph):

 * resolution:   => pushed
 * status:  new => closed


Comment:

 Hey, so.. I opened this ticket to provide a place for people to comment on
 the controversy if they were motivated to do so.  Thanks for the comments
 so far.

 There's clearly disagreement about it, but it doesn't seem to be
 overwhelmingly on one side or the other (I, for one, like the negative
 badges).  How about this for a resolution:

 - We don't go back and change the existing negative badges, only because
 it would be an exceptional amount of work to remove them (it will screw
 with the badge-counting badges).
 - We make a point to not introduce any more negative badges from here on
 out, which will lead to an overwhelming ratio of positive to negative
 badges in time.

 I'm closing the ticket to get it out of the queue, but feel free to
 comment further if there's discussion.

-- 
Ticket URL: <https://fedorahosted.org/fedora-badges/ticket/112#comment:5>
fedora-badges <https://badges.fedoraproject.org>
A place to collect and debate badge ideas for the Fedora Badges app