#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: | Owner: till | Status: new Type: | Keywords: New badge idea | Has a description: 0 Priority: | Artwork status: None minor | External requirements: Has a name: | Triaged (triagers only): 0 0 | Concept approved (reviewers only): | 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 | -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- What the badge should be granted for: Setting up FreeOTP Badge description (like "You added a co-maintainer to a package. BFF!"): You setup FreeOTP for your FAS account Anything else we need to know: This is similar to the yubikey badge, but it doable without purchasing a yubikey: https://infrastructure.fedoraproject.org/infra/docs/2-factor.txt
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: None | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by riecatnor):
Possible Artwork Concept: Same as the horcrux badge, but use a phone instead of a yubikey https://badges.fedoraproject.org/badge/horcrux
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by riecatnor):
* has_artwork: None => Concept
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Concept | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by robyduck):
What about this artwork proposal? [[Image(freeOTP.png)]]
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Proposed | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by robyduck):
* has_artwork: Concept => Proposed
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Proposed | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by riecatnor):
This is a great start!
I think that it could use a few small adjustments to fit the aesthetics of Fedora Badges.
We avoid making plain black objects when possible(though a few have snuck in), perhaps try making it dark grey with a black stroke, or black with a dark grey stroke. You could even make it in all variations of grey, or even Fedora colors! I think the screen of the cell phone should be a light, and it might look nice with a gradient to white. The 'button' should follow the color pallet you choose. The yellow is sticking out to me a bit.
I like the tilted composition, but I think its slightly too tilted to the right. Try different degrees of rotation.
Thanks for your work :)
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Proposed | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by robyduck):
Not sure if that is what you meant, but here it is :)
[[Image(freeOTP2.png)]]
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Proposed | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by riecatnor):
@robyduck, you did a great job following my suggestions! I wanted to take a closer look at your artwork, and possibly play around with it, but I found the graphics inside the svg were bitmap. Not sure how you got there, but its best to draw your objects in vector form, so future artists can edit them :)
I was looking at your newest iteration thinking something is still not quite right. So I researched other FAS account badges, and you were on the right track including the orange. Most of them have completely orange objects with some white, or a little grey. I think that this badge follows most closely to the yubikey badge so I identified some characteristics that should be used for this badge.
I took a few minutes to redraw your design, and tried to emulate the yubikey theme. Here is what I came up with:
[[Image(freeotp3.png)]]
I think giving it that 3D look makes it look a lot closer to the yubikey badge, and I also incorporated some lighter orange so as to not clash with the grey.
Let me know your thoughts! If you want to play around with the design, feel free :)
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Proposed | Concept approved (reviewers only): External requirements: | 0 Triaged (triagers only): 0 | Badge definition status: | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+-------------------------------------
Comment (by robyduck):
Oooh, wow, yes this is great. Yeah, I've choosen the orange because the yubi-key was grey and orange, but this background in the screen is very nice. And the 3D is perfect IMO. I'm fine with this design, like it very much :)
#346: Badge for setting up FreeOTP -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Reporter: till | Owner: Type: New badge | Status: idea | new Priority: minor | Resolution: Keywords: | Has a name: Has a description: 0 | 0 Artwork status: Approved | Concept approved (reviewers only): (design team members only) | 0 External requirements: | Badge definition status: Triaged (triagers only): 0 | None | Manually awarded: | 0 -------------------------------------+------------------------------------- Changes (by riecatnor):
* has_artwork: Proposed => Approved (design team members only)
Comment:
Awesome! When you collaborate on a badge you still get credit for the design, so don't forget to update the artwork log :)
badges@lists.fedoraproject.org