I agree with Steven and Nicu. I think that best candidates for official wallpaper are:

* Tatica's "Pruebas"

* Samuele's "4 horses"

* Nicu/Mo's Underwater mosaic designs

Question: alpha banner can be generic (like F11 Alpha banner) or it must be themed?

Thank you.

~p

2009/7/29 Steven Moix <steven.moix@axianet.ch>
Hello all,

As Nicu requested on his blog [1], I'm providing my very own personal
feedback about the wallpapers displayed on [2]. I'll give my top 5 (in
no particular order) with comments:

* Tatica's "four foundations mosaic" has a clean design, not too
overloaded. It's one of my favourite designs, but it has one flaw: it's
a great but pretty generic wallpaper when it comes to the Constantine theme.
* Tatica's "Pruebas" design is great, the buildings take a bit too much
space but well, it's an alpha design. It fits the Constantine theme very
well.
* Samuele's "4Flowers" is clean, simple and beautiful. It should be a
bit more "Fedora blue" IMO.
* Nicu/Mo's Underwater mosaic designs are the most generic (in a good
sense) and best design ideas IMO. They fit an oriental theme, they fit
the Fedora colours and are not too overloaded.
* Jayme Ayre's blue Constantine also has a great potential. It fits the
Fedora colours, it's not too overloaded but it might have a
political/religious connotation?

I didn't chose most of the other themes for one simple reason: too
overloaded.

So here you go...my 2 cents as a standard user.

1: http://nicubunu.blogspot.com/2009/07/artwork-for-fedora-12-alpha.html
2: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/F12_Artwork#Concepts.2C_WIP_Designs

Have a nice day.
Steven
_______________________________________________
design-team mailing list
design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/design-team



--
Paolo Leoni ~ http://pleoni.altervista.org