So I vote 1 for the first one, 3 for the second one, 0 for the third one.
On 2014/4/21 14:13, Zamir SUN wrote:
Link : [1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo-...
[2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B...
[3] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B...
On 04/22/2014 10:05 AM, Zamir SUN wrote:
So I vote 1 for the first one, 3 for the second one, 0 for the third one.
I vote 3 for the first one, 1 for the second one, 2 for the third one.
Regards,
I vote:
+1 for the first one; 0 for the second one; +3 for the last one.
Yours sincerely, Christopher Meng
Noob here.
Just a reminder :
The "Beijing" text in [2] and [3] is not as per guidelines. It won't maintain uniformity with previous FUDCons. I have no clue if this really will be an issue. I like the calligraphic text style though. There is also a modified version of Prima's original logo which was left out [4]. If organizers are considering voting, we can include that too. So the list now is as follows :
[1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo-... [2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [3] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [4] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo....
-- Suchakra
Hi,
On 04/22/2014 09:35 AM, Suchakra wrote:
The "Beijing" text in [2] and [3] is not as per guidelines. It won't maintain uniformity with previous FUDCons. I have no clue if this really will be an issue. I like the calligraphic text style though. There is also a modified version of Prima's original logo which was left out [4]. If organizers are considering voting, we can include that too. So the list now is as follows :
Folks, we have to follow the logo guidelines to protect our logo. Options [1] and [4] below are fine. [2] and [3] are not and directly violate the guidelines. The guidelines are here, for reference:
https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Logo/UsageGuidelines#Guidelines_4
I know it's a bummer, but there is a lot of room for creativity and expression here in the graphic that accompanies the logo type, and honestly you have done a great job creating gorgeous graphics for that, so maybe let's leave the logotype alone?
[1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo-... [2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [3] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [4] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo....
~m
Hi,
I change the "Beijing" font as per guidelines [1][2].
[1] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B...
On Tue, Apr 22, 2014 at 10:15 PM, Máirín Duffy duffy@fedoraproject.orgwrote:
Hi,
On 04/22/2014 09:35 AM, Suchakra wrote:
The "Beijing" text in [2] and [3] is not as per guidelines. It won't maintain uniformity with previous FUDCons. I have no clue if this really will be an issue. I like the calligraphic text style though. There is also a modified version of Prima's original logo which was left out [4]. If organizers are considering voting, we can include that too. So the list now is as follows :
Folks, we have to follow the logo guidelines to protect our logo. Options [1] and [4] below are fine. [2] and [3] are not and directly violate the guidelines. The guidelines are here, for reference:
https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Logo/UsageGuidelines#Guidelines_4
I know it's a bummer, but there is a lot of room for creativity and expression here in the graphic that accompanies the logo type, and honestly you have done a great job creating gorgeous graphics for that, so maybe let's leave the logotype alone?
[1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/
fudcon-beijing-logo-2.png [2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/ FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-Beijing-Logo-Caligraphic.png [3] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/ FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-Beijing-Logo-Skyscraper.png [4] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/ fudcon-beijing-logo.png
~m
design-team mailing list design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org https://lists.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/design-team
Hi Prima,
Thanks! It looks like the font for 'fudcon' is wrong though. If you need the fudcon logo template files let me know and I can send them. The 'd' in fudcon should have a foot and it doesn't - that tells me it's in Comfortaa. The fudcon font is not Comfortaa. You can read more about the logo guidelines and templates etc here:
https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Logo/UsageGuidelines#Guidelines_4
A few other points:
For FUDCon-Beijing-Logo-City.svg ---------------------------------
1) The stroke around the city is blowing out the actual artwork. This is especially apparent on the windows of the rightmost windowed building. I would suggest duplicating the cityscape and removing the stroke so the stroke is outside-only instead of outside and insnide.
2) The FUDcon logomark (The 4 speech bubbles) isn't center-aligned to the white outline. Again, I strongly suggest using the FUDcon logo template files, because the templates have this all centered and taken care of in the right font.
For FUDCon-Beijing-Logo-TempleOfHeaven.svg ------------------------------------------
1) The artwork looks like a scan that still needs some cleanup. There's artifacts floating around the outside of the temple, both above it and to the right, and to the left. The junction between the fudcon logo mark and logotype is also awkward - see the strange shape created between the 'f' of 'fudcon' and the white outline of the fudcon speech bubble logomarks.
Hope this helps
~m
On 04/22/2014 01:25 PM, Prima Yogi Loviniltra wrote:
[1]http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [2]http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B...
On Tue, Apr 22, 2014 at 10:15 PM, Máirín Duffy <duffy@fedoraproject.org mailto:duffy@fedoraproject.org> wrote:
Hi, On 04/22/2014 09:35 AM, Suchakra wrote: The "Beijing" text in [2] and [3] is not as per guidelines. It won't maintain uniformity with previous FUDCons. I have no clue if this really will be an issue. I like the calligraphic text style though. There is also a modified version of Prima's original logo which was left out [4]. If organizers are considering voting, we can include that too. So the list now is as follows : Folks, we have to follow the logo guidelines to protect our logo. Options [1] and [4] below are fine. [2] and [3] are not and directly violate the guidelines. The guidelines are here, for reference: https://fedoraproject.org/__wiki/Logo/UsageGuidelines#__Guidelines_4 <https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Logo/UsageGuidelines#Guidelines_4> I know it's a bummer, but there is a lot of room for creativity and expression here in the graphic that accompanies the logo type, and honestly you have done a great job creating gorgeous graphics for that, so maybe let's leave the logotype alone? [1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.__org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/__fudcon-beijing-logo-2.png <http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo-2.png> [2] http://jurankdankkal.__fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/__FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-__Beijing-Logo-Caligraphic.png <http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-Beijing-Logo-Caligraphic.png> [3] http://jurankdankkal.__fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/__FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-__Beijing-Logo-Skyscraper.png <http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-Beijing-Logo-Skyscraper.png> [4] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.__org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/__fudcon-beijing-logo.png <http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo.png> ~m _________________________________________________ design-team mailing list design-team@lists.__fedoraproject.org <mailto:design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org> https://lists.fedoraproject.__org/mailman/listinfo/design-__team <https://lists.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/design-team>
design-team mailing list design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org https://lists.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/design-team
Hey guys,
Thanks for your efforts. I think we should consider to vote again from scratch. The candidates are as follows. Please review each of them carefully. Range voting is still used, but the range is changed to 0--4.
[1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo-... [2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [3] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [4] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo....
Note: let's assume [2][3] will have correct font used in the final version.
Regards,
My own vote is: 4, 2, 1, 1.
Thank you guys.
I still prefer the Temple of Heaven one.(Yes,the font should be corrected) So my vote is
[1] 2 [2] 0 [3] 4 [4] 3
On 2014/4/25 16:39, Alick Zhao wrote:
Hey guys,
Thanks for your efforts. I think we should consider to vote again from scratch. The candidates are as follows. Please review each of them carefully. Range voting is still used, but the range is changed to 0--4.
[1] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo-... [2] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [3] http://jurankdankkal.fedorapeople.org/FUDCon/FUDConBeijing2014/Logo/FUDCon-B... [4] http://suchakra.fedorapeople.org/fudcon-designs/Beijing/fudcon-beijing-logo....
Note: let's assume [2][3] will have correct font used in the final version.
Regards,
Hi,
my vote: [1] 4 [2] 0 [3] 2 [4] 1
Regards, Martin
design-team@lists.fedoraproject.org
-
Alick Zhao -
Christopher Meng -
Martin Sourada -
Máirín Duffy -
Prima Yogi Loviniltra -
Suchakra -
Zamir Sun