Re: Backwards incompatible changes planned for Bodhi 4.0.0

[Randy Barlow]

On Fri, 2018-12-14 at 09:10 +0000, Mattia Verga wrote:
>  Il 12/13/18 3:36 PM, Randy Barlow ha scritto:
>  > * Remove critpath karma[5].
>  > 
>  I know Fedora wants to move to a more community driven process, but
>  I 
>  think the ideas behind adamw proposal [1] of the critpath field are 
>  still valid. 
I'm not opposed to keeping critical path karma if it's believed to be
useful.

>  I think we could make regular users post regular karma only and 
>  provenpackagers/proventesters post critpath karma only (or whatever
>  we 
>  decide to name it). The karma of an update would be calculated by
>  the 
>  sum of karma + critpath karma, BUT if a negative critpath karma
>  exists, 
>  the autopush feature would be disabled (for example, 4 regular users 
>  give +1 and a proventester gives -1, the overall karma would be +3
>  and 
>  the threshold for autopush is reached, but the update is not pushed 
>  because of proventester feedback). 
I don't believe we have proven testers anymore, do we? We already
disable autopush on any negative karma today - I don't believe we
should require a proven packager/tester's negative karma to disable
autopusing.