Regarding GPL compatibility of fdk-aac
by Tom Callaway
The Fedora Project is aware that the Free Software Foundation has stated
that the Fraunhofer FDK AAC license is GPL incompatible, specifically,
because of Clause 3.
We believe that the fdk-aac software codec implementation that we wish to
include in Fedora is no longer encumbered by AAC patents. This fact means
that Clause 3 in the FDK AAC license is a "no op", or to put it plainly, if
no patents are in play, there are no patent licenses to disclaim. For this
(and only this) specific implementation of fdk-aac, we believe that the FDK
AAC license is GPL compatible.
Thanks,
Tom
8 months, 2 weeks
License mix of package "anki"
by Christian Krause
Hi,
I'm currently in the process of updating the package anki to a new
major release for which I need guidance regarding the mix of
licensing.
Originally I was setting the bug report for the new release ([1]) to
block FE-Legal in order to get confirmation that my findings regarding
the licenses are OK and acceptable for Fedora. Since I haven't
received any feedback for a while, that was probably not the best way
to reach the FE-Legal team and so I'll repeat my question here:
---------------------------------------------------------------
The new major version of anki 2.1.x includes some new files with new
licenses. Upstream has updated the LICENSE file(s) accordingly.
IMHO this would result in the following License tag in the spec file:
License: AGPLv3+ and GPLv3+ and LGPLv3+ and MIT and BSD and ASL
2.0 and CC-BY-SA and CC-BY
Please can FE-Legal confirm, that this combination of licenses is OK?
As reference, here are the relevant snippets of the two license files:
1. LICENSE
[...]
The following included source code items use a license other than AGPL3:
* Anki's translations: BSD.
* Qt's bundled translations: LGPL3.
* The anki/template/ folder is based off pystache: MIT.
* The SuperMemo importer: GPL3.
* The Pauker importer: BSD-3.
* mpv.py: MIT.
* statsbg.py: CC BY-SA 3.0.
* winpaths.py: MIT.
* MathJax: Apache 2.
* jQuery and jQuery-UI: MIT.
* browsersel.js: CC BY 2.5.
* plot.js: MIT.
[...]
2. LICENSE.logo:
[...]
Anki's logo is copyright Alex Fraser, and is licensed under the AGPL3 like the
[...]
The official source of the tarball which includes the complete license
files can be found here:
https://apps.ankiweb.net/downloads/current/anki-2.1.12-source.tgz
---------------------------------------------------------------
Thank you very much in advance!
Best regards,
Christian
[1] https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1612847
8 months, 3 weeks
