Hello everyone,
there are plenty of Python packages in Fedora currently using setuptools at buildtime but not all of them are BuildRequiring it explicitly. This only works because python3-devel (transitively) depends on python3-setuptools.
We would like to kindly ask you to add explicit BuildRequires for python3-setuptools to packages where setuptools is used. It will help us with testing new versions of setuptools in the future or with decoupling Python and setuptools. Today, if we want to know if a package is using setuptools, we have to do `fedpkg prep` and use grep to search for setuptools. Using a repoquery is much more convenient.
Several packages can successfully build either with or without setuptools (they use try-except import and fallback to distutils from the standard library). Such packages are especially dangerous when not BuildRequiring setuptools -- they can produce different results depending on the presence of setuptools: either an .egg-info metadata directory (w/setuptools) or .egg-info text file (w/distutils). RPM has troubles when upgrading directories to files [1].
[1] https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/packaging-guidelines/Directory_Replacem...
According to our grep based query on Fedora Rawhide, there are 621 known packages using setuptools without BuildRequiring it at this point:
Thank you very much for your help with this.
On behalf of python-setuptools maintainers, Tomáš Hrnčiar
Maintainers by package: 0ad ignatenkobrain pcpa pwalter APLpy sergiopr skytux COPASI sagitter OpenMolcas jussilehtola ProDy sagitter PyGreSQL hhorak jmlich odubaj panovotn pkajaba pkubat praiskup PySolFC sergiomb shlomif R2spec pingou ViTables tnorth zbyszek androguard fab ansible-review dcallagh ttrinks artifacts fab borgmatic heffer btrfs-sxbackup thofmann bumpversion duriantang jdornak cantoolz fab cinch greghellings commissaire-client mbarnes smilner compose-utils lsedlar condor bbockelm bcotton eerlands matt matyas stevetraylen tstclair ttheisen valtri congruity adamwill swt2c copr-messaging schlupov copydeps suve cppcheck c72578 jussilehtola sgrubb cranc lenkaseg crudini apevec jruzicka pbrady cxxtest mgieseki datanommer ralph dblatex alexlan jchaloup mjg dnstwist suve dogtag-pki cipherboy dmoluguw edewata kwright mharmsen vakwetu dolfin limb zbyszek dot2tex thofmann electrum jonny expliot fab fail2ban atkac hobbes1069 jgu orion fedora-messaging abompard file kdudka macermak odubaj svashisht vmihalko flatcam dwrobel flawfinder athoscr flent adrian tohojo fontdump pnemade fontforge frixxon kevin pnemade fonttools pnemade tagoh freeipa-healthcheck abbra cheimes fcami mkosek pvoborni rcritten twoerner frescobaldi limb gajim michich gau2grid jussilehtola gdal alexlan devrim jmlich mmahut neteler oliver orion pali praiskup smani volter gedit-plugin-editorconfig ferdnyc gfal2-python adev andreamanzi gbitzes ginga lupinix git-filter-repo asn git-up mhjacks gns3-gui kwizart gns3-net-converter kwizart gns3-server kwizart nucleo gtimelog amigadave h5py stevetraylen terjeros hashid fab hgview kiilerix home-assistant-cli fab httpie codeblock ralph inception fab inkscape duffy jgu limb lkundrak ioc-writer fab irclog2html fab isrcsubmit amigadave koji ausil kevin mikem puiterwijk lammps ellio167 junghans legendary atim legofy lkf williamjmorenor libCombine sagitter libcaca hubbitus slaanesh thias libolm xvitaly librealsense thofmann libreoffice caolanm dtardon erack sbergmann libxc jussilehtola lldb airlied daveisfera jankratochvil sergesanspaille siddharths tstellar llvm dmalcolm ignatenkobrain jakub jistone kyle scottt sergesanspaille siddharths tstellar llvm7.0 jistone petersen sergesanspaille tstellar llvm9.0 jistone sergesanspaille tstellar mercurial kiilerix nbecker pstodulk mgarepo misc ngompa minigalaxy atim mkdocs-bootstrap cheeselee mkdocs-cinder cheeselee mkdocs-material cheeselee mod_wsgi jdornak jkaluza jorton lmacken mrunge modtools dhodovsk phracek ttomecek modulemd-tools frostyx moose zbyszek mopidy-mpd girst mozjs68 frantisekz kalev mpi4py deji limb tomspur mypaint avsej mysql-connector-python hhorak hubbitus hvad mschorm nodejs mrunge patches piotrp sgallagh zvetlik nototools mfabian pwu officeparser rebus offlineimap cicku dodji notting sergesanspaille teuf ogr2osm musuruan opae aravuri nkorde trix openbabel itamarjp jussilehtola rathann oval-graph hony past-time fab pcapy limb pcp agerstmayr lberk mgoodwin nathans pcp2pdf lberk mbaldessari pdfarranger dreua fab fschwarz pdfposter fab percol hubbitus petsc sagitter petsc4py sagitter picard alexlan cicku gbcox ohaessler pipsi cstratak mstuchli pipx mhjacks pki-core cipherboy dmoluguw edewata kwright mharmsen vakwetu poezio fantom louizatakk porcupine kushal portmidi eeickmeyer mjg xavierb protonvpn-cli jflory7 prunerepo clime frostyx py-bcrypt kevin limb py3c pviktori pyaudio chkr pybluez limb pycolumnize fab kushal pyephem elwell orphan pygobject3 johnp nacho walters pygsl jamatos pyhunspell mfabian till pykka fab pylast fab peter pylibacl frankcrawford kevin szpak pyodbc fjanus hhorak pyosmium tomh pyproj jdekloe pyscard sjenning pyserial stingray pysubnettree fab python-CommonMark jujens python-GeoIP pingou ralph sergiomb totol python-GridDataFormats rathann python-OBD rathann python-PyLEMS ankursinha python-Pyped uggla python-Rtree volter python-SALib ankursinha python-acme jhogarth nb python-acoustid terjeros python-agate jujens python-aiodns fantom python-airspeed ankursinha python-alsa limb perex python-aniso8601 jsedlak kparal python-ansicolors skisela python-apipkg fab ktdreyer thm python-apprise lead2gold python-apsw cicku dfateyev maci python-arviz sergiopr python-ase besser82 marcindulak python-astral fab python-astroplan sergiopr python-astropy-healpix lupinix python-astroquery lupinix python-astroscrappy lupinix python-asttokens zbyszek python-asyncssh gsauthof python-audioread terjeros python-autobahn jujens python-autopep8 mrunge ndipanov python-babelfish jorti python-basemap jspaleta limb python-betamax-matchers fab python-betamax-serializers fab python-bigsuds xavierb python-biopython alexlan lbazan rathann sagitter python-bloom cottsay rmattes python-blosc tnorth zbyszek python-box dmsimard python-btchip jonny xenithorb python-cached_property adamwill immanetize python-cachetools jeckersb python-cachez eharney python-carbon jsteffan piotrp python-ccdproc lupinix python-certbot-apache jhogarth nb python-chai kevin pingou ralph python-click-plugins qulogic python-cloud-sptheme kevin ralph python-cmigemo hubbitus python-colorlog fab python-colorspacious rathann python-conda-package-handling orion python-construct moezroy terjeros python-contextlib2 abompard pingou ralph tjikkun python-convertdate fab python-cookiecutter wakko666 python-coveralls bcl python-crcelk fab python-crochet abompard python-css-parser zbyszek python-dateparser fab limb python-dbfread jujens python-debrepo ktdreyer python-decopatch zbyszek python-descartes qulogic python-dfdatetime fab python-dialog itamarjp mjakubicek noodles raphgro sundaram zbyszek python-diff-match-patch amigadave python-dijitso zbyszek python-dill sergiopr python-django bkabrda churchyard jdornak mrunge rdopiera salimma sgallagh python-django-contact-form mrunge python-django-formtools jpena mrunge python-django-health-check dmsimard python-django-registration kumarpraveen python-django-reversion mrunge python-django-tagging jdornak mrunge piotrp python-django-tastypie bkabrda cquad mrunge stevetraylen python-djangoql vkrizan python-docx kushal124 python-dpkt mbaldessari python-dtfabric fab python-duecredit ankursinha python-dukpy zbyszek python-dulwich fab python-edgegrid rohanpm python-editdistance major python-editorconfig barracks510 python-efel ankursinha python-emcee sergiopr python-emoji xvitaly python-enthought-sphinx-theme orion python-enzyme jorti python-et_xmlfile jujens python-etcd mbarnes smilner python-faker jorti python-fasteners mrunge python-fastpurge rohanpm python-feedgenerator ankursinha python-ffc zbyszek python-fiat fab python-fido2 orion python-fields cottsay python-filetype fab python-firkin fab python-fisx zbyszek python-fitsio lupinix python-flake8-docstrings cottsay python-flask-gravatar devrim itamarjp python-flask-htmlmin devrim itamarjp python-flask-paranoid devrim itamarjp python-flask-rstpages rmarko python-flask-security devrim itamarjp python-flask-sphinx-themes devrim itamarjp python-formats uggla python-fs pnemade python-fsleyes ankursinha python-fsleyes-props ankursinha python-fsleyes-widgets ankursinha python-fslpy ankursinha python-fuse jorti python-fypp rathann python-geopandas qulogic python-gevent dcallagh ignatenkobrain orion skottler python-giacpy sagitter python-glances-api fab python-gsd rathann python-guessit jorti python-heapdict qulogic python-hl7 ankursinha python-hole fab python-html5-parser kevin python-htmlmin jujens python-humblewx rickardlindberg python-hupper kevin python-i3ipc msimacek python-idstools jtaylor marcindulak python-ifcfg cottsay python-igraph bstinson limb pingou python-img2pdf gsauthof python-indexed_gzip ankursinha python-inema gsauthof python-inotify jfilak stevetraylen terjeros python-inotify_simple praiskup python-instant fab python-intervaltree mikep python-ipykernel churchyard pcpa python-ipyparallel ellert python-iso-639 melmorabity python-iso3166 melmorabity python-javalang fab python-jep raphgro python-jinja2-cli jujens python-jinja2-time wakko666 python-jnius raphgro python-joblib besser82 ignatenkobrain sergiopr python-journal-brief twaugh python-jsonmodels oanson python-jsonrpclib ihrachyshka jonny python-junit_xml jhogarth python-kaitaistruct rathann python-kdcproxy rharwood python-kerberos rcritten simo python-kitchen kevin pingou ralph python-kiwisolver qulogic python-klusta ankursinha python-landslide echevemaster python-lark-parser totol python-leather jujens python-libNeuroML ankursinha python-libnacl jonny sergiomb python-libsass dormouse python-libusb1 jonny python-lmdb pspacek python-logzero somlo python-luftdaten fab python-lunr cheeselee python-m2r nforro python-makefun zbyszek python-mapnik tomh python-markdown2 thm python-matplotlib-scalebar ankursinha python-mdp zbyszek python-mdx_gh_links cheeselee python-meld3 kevin stevetraylen tsao python-metakernel ellert python-metar jdekloe thias python-migen somlo python-minibelt uggla python-mmtf rathann python-mnemonic jonny python-mongoquery mkrizek python-more-executors rohanpm python-more-itertools aarem churchyard jcaratzas python-music21 zbyszek python-mutagen cicku ignatenkobrain mbaldessari moezroy python-mwclient adamwill rdieter tuxbrewr python-myhdl filiperosset python-mystrom fab python-ndg_httpsclient churchyard fschwarz itamarjp noodles python-netdata fab python-networkmanager jdulaney python-neurodsp major python-nilearn ankursinha python-nistats ankursinha python-nitime ankursinha python-nixio ankursinha python-nmrglue nonamedotc python-node-semver xvitaly python-notario ktdreyer python-oauth2 ignatenkobrain pjp spot sundaram python-octave-kernel qulogic python-odml major python-oletools rebus robert python-opendata-transport fab python-openoffice sharkcz python-opensensemap-api fab python-paho-mqtt fab python-pandas-datareader sergiopr python-partd qulogic python-paste-script andreamanzi dcallagh python-patch-ng xvitaly python-pathlib2 pcpa python-patsy sergiopr python-pbkdf2 jonny python-pcodedmp robert python-pdfrw fschwarz sergiopr slaanesh python-pecan-notario ktdreyer python-pelican firemanxbr mrunge python-pep8-naming qulogic python-periodictable sagitter python-persist-queue eharney python-petlink ankursinha python-pexpect amcnabb fabiand ignatenkobrain radez swt2c tomspur python-photutils sergiopr python-pingouin ankursinha python-pkginfo decathorpe fab pcreech17 python-plaster-pastedeploy abompard python-play-scraper fab python-plumbum greghellings lorenzodalrio python-pocketlint jkonecny vtrefny python-polib cicku dchen diegobz dshea ivazquez moezroy suanand python-poyo wakko666 python-prawcore fab python-precis_i18n michich python-proteus sharkcz python-psutil salimma python-publicsuffix2 rathann python-pulsectl pfrields python-pvc raphgro python-pycares fantom python-pycha potty sharkcz python-pycosat orion python-pycurl jsynacek kdudka msekleta svashisht python-pydocstyle tadej python-pyeclib hguemar zaitcev python-pyelectro ankursinha python-pyemd ankursinha python-pygeoip kevin ralph python-pylatex ankursinha python-pylons-sphinx-themes abompard python-pymatreader ankursinha python-pyotp icon python-pypcapkit fab python-pypet ankursinha python-pypng kevin ralph python-pypubsub swt2c python-pyramid_sawing abompard python-pyrfc3339 fschwarz itamarjp jhogarth noodles python-pysb zbyszek python-pysignals kni python-pysrt jorti python-pytelegrambotapi xvitaly python-pytest-aiohttp fab python-pytest-astropy-header sergiopr python-pytest-benchmark jorti python-pytest-cases zbyszek python-pytest-faulthandler dkrejci lbalhar python-pytest-fixture-config kevin python-pytest-forked swt2c python-pytest-harvest zbyszek python-pytest-lazy-fixture ankursinha python-pytest-mock jujens python-pytest-repeat cottsay python-pytest-shutil kevin python-pytest-steps zbyszek python-pytest-timeout swt2c python-pytest-tornado qulogic python-pytest-vcr limb python-pytest-virtualenv kevin python-pytest-watch jujens python-pytest-xdist swt2c python-pyvit fab python-pyvo lupinix python-queuelib fab python-rarfile fab python-rebulk jorti python-recommonmark jujens python-relatorio sharkcz python-rencode jgu orion patches python-reportlab sagitter python-represent dkrejci lbalhar python-reproject lupinix python-requests-cache codeblock hobbes1069 python-requests-futures fab python-restructuredtext-lint jujens python-retrying apevec python-retryz eharney python-rmtest lberk mgoodwin nathans python-rope nonamedotc python-rosdep cottsay rmattes thofmann python-rpmautospec asaleh nphilipp python-sanction kevin ralph python-scales filabrazilska lbalhar lkundrak python-scikit-learn besser82 ignatenkobrain lupinix sergiopr python-sciunit ankursinha python-scrapy echevemaster python-setuptools-lint jdulaney python-shamir-mnemonic jonny python-sieve kevin ondrejj ralph python-simplemediawiki lmacken potty ralph python-simpleparse grover mlombard python-slixmpp fantom louizatakk python-snappy jujens python-social-auth-core cqi python-soupsieve zbyszek python-spdx jbertozzi python-spdx-lookup jbertozzi python-sphinxcontrib-issuetracker orion python-sphinxcontrib-svg2pdfconverter belegdol python-sql sharkcz python-ssdeep suve python-statsd pabelanger tdecacqu python-statsmodels sergiopr python-steps ankursinha python-subliminal jorti python-suds jortel swt2c python-sybil fab python-tables tnorth zbyszek python-tasklib ankursinha python-tblib qulogic python-tbtrim fab python-tempdir rathann python-testfixtures fab python-testing.postgresql ekulik mmarusak msuchy python-timeout-decorator jcapitao python-tinycss2 brouhaha fschwarz python-tinydb suanand python-toml jujens python-tortilla uggla python-tree-format chedi wakko666 python-trezor jonny python-twilio mich181189 python-txaio jujens python-ufl fab python-unidecode pjp sundaram python-unidiff dcallagh python-upt-cpan jbertozzi python-upt-fedora jbertozzi python-upt-pypi jbertozzi python-upt-rubygems jbertozzi python-urwidtrees ttomecek python-validators fab python-varlink harald python-virtualenv-clone ralph tadej python-volkszaehler fab python-wand barracks510 python-watchdog jsteffan jujens pingou python-webcolors dridi python-webencodings abompard python-webpy mrunge python-webthing-ws fab python-winrm jhogarth python-wloc xvitaly python-wsaccel jujens python-xlib jspaleta orion potty python-xlwt leamas moezroy rathann python-xml2rfc pwouters python-xmltodict fab ralph python-xvfbwrapper mrunge totol python-zeep gsauthof python-zict qulogic python-zodbpickle jjames python-zstandard rathann python3-exiv2 asn python3-mallard-ducktype amigadave python3-poppler-qt5 limb python3-pytest-asyncio jujens python3-saml dcallagh pyusb limb pyxattr defolos frankcrawford kevin szpak qemu amitshah berrange bonzini crobinso dwmw2 ehabkost jforbes lkundrak quintela rjones rdiff-backup frankcrawford kevin rdkit giallu rpl timj rpmdeplint dcallagh frantisekz mvadkert rpmspectool nphilipp rst2txt fab salt dmurphy18 samba abbra anoopcs asn gd iboukris jarrpa jlayton jstephen obnox simo scribus pwalter sharkcz tripledes sentencepiece kenhys sepolicy_analysis vmojzis seqan sagitter shyaml thofmann solaar brouhaha rathann richardfearn tibbs solarwolf limb sos-collector turboturtle spec2scl jstanek spglib sagitter spyder nonamedotc thozza starcal hedayat stomppy stevetraylen swid-tools adelton swift-lang tachoknight sympy cbm jjames jussilehtola orion texlive-base spot thonny aivarannamaa churchyard thrift ctubbsii milleruntime orion tortoisehg kiilerix nbecker tpm2-pkcs11 jjelen pbrobinson translate-toolkit cicku dwayne petersen suanand tryton sharkcz trytond sharkcz trytond-account sharkcz trytond-account-be sharkcz trytond-account-de-skr03 sharkcz trytond-account-invoice sharkcz trytond-account-invoice-history sharkcz trytond-account-invoice-line-standalone sharkcz trytond-account-product sharkcz trytond-account-statement sharkcz trytond-account-stock-anglo-saxon sharkcz trytond-account-stock-continental sharkcz trytond-analytic-account sharkcz trytond-analytic-invoice sharkcz trytond-analytic-purchase sharkcz trytond-analytic-sale sharkcz trytond-company sharkcz trytond-company-work-time sharkcz trytond-country sharkcz trytond-currency sharkcz trytond-dashboard sharkcz trytond-google-maps sharkcz trytond-ldap-authentication sharkcz trytond-party sharkcz trytond-party-siret sharkcz trytond-product sharkcz trytond-product-cost-fifo sharkcz trytond-product-cost-history sharkcz trytond-product-price-list sharkcz trytond-project sharkcz trytond-project-plan sharkcz trytond-project-revenue sharkcz trytond-purchase sharkcz trytond-purchase-invoice-line-standalone sharkcz trytond-sale sharkcz trytond-sale-opportunity sharkcz trytond-sale-price-list sharkcz trytond-stock sharkcz trytond-stock-forecast sharkcz trytond-stock-inventory-location sharkcz trytond-stock-location-sequence sharkcz trytond-stock-product-location sharkcz trytond-stock-supply sharkcz trytond-stock-supply-day sharkcz trytond-timesheet sharkcz uhd jskarvad upt jbertozzi uwsgi kad wafw00f fab wine-mono mooninite winpdb spot xortool fab xrootd ellert simonm xtensor-python sergesanspaille yawn jsafrane miminar vcrhonek yubikey-manager gbcox sjenning
Packages by maintainer: aarem python-more-itertools abbra freeipa-healthcheck samba abompard fedora-messaging python-contextlib2 python-crochet python-plaster-pastedeploy python-pylons-sphinx-themes python-pyramid_sawing python-webencodings adamwill congruity python-cached_property python-mwclient adelton swid-tools adev gfal2-python adrian flent agerstmayr pcp airlied lldb aivarannamaa thonny alexlan dblatex gdal picard python-biopython amcnabb python-pexpect amigadave gtimelog isrcsubmit python-diff-match-patch python3-mallard-ducktype amitshah qemu andreamanzi gfal2-python python-paste-script ankursinha python-PyLEMS python-SALib python-airspeed python-duecredit python-efel python-feedgenerator python-fsleyes python-fsleyes-props python-fsleyes-widgets python-fslpy python-hl7 python-indexed_gzip python-klusta python-libNeuroML python-matplotlib-scalebar python-nilearn python-nistats python-nitime python-nixio python-petlink python-pingouin python-pyelectro python-pyemd python-pylatex python-pymatreader python-pypet python-pytest-lazy-fixture python-sciunit python-steps python-tasklib anoopcs samba apevec crudini python-retrying aravuri opae asaleh python-rpmautospec asn git-filter-repo python3-exiv2 samba athoscr flawfinder atim legendary minigalaxy atkac fail2ban ausil koji avsej mypaint barracks510 python-editorconfig python-wand bbockelm condor bcl python-coveralls bcotton condor belegdol python-sphinxcontrib-svg2pdfconverter berrange qemu besser82 python-ase python-joblib python-scikit-learn bkabrda python-django python-django-tastypie bonzini qemu brouhaha python-tinycss2 solaar bstinson python-igraph c72578 cppcheck caolanm libreoffice cbm sympy chedi python-tree-format cheeselee mkdocs-bootstrap mkdocs-cinder mkdocs-material python-lunr python-mdx_gh_links cheimes freeipa-healthcheck chkr pyaudio churchyard python-django python-ipykernel python-more-itertools python-ndg_httpsclient thonny cicku offlineimap picard python-apsw python-mutagen python-polib translate-toolkit cipherboy dogtag-pki pki-core clime prunerepo codeblock httpie python-requests-cache cottsay python-bloom python-fields python-flake8-docstrings python-ifcfg python-pytest-repeat python-rosdep cqi python-social-auth-core cquad python-django-tastypie crobinso qemu cstratak pipsi ctubbsii thrift daveisfera lldb dcallagh ansible-review python-gevent python-paste-script python-unidiff python3-saml rpmdeplint dchen python-polib decathorpe python-pkginfo defolos pyxattr deji mpi4py devrim gdal python-flask-gravatar python-flask-htmlmin python-flask-paranoid python-flask-security python-flask-sphinx-themes dfateyev python-apsw dhodovsk modtools diegobz python-polib dkrejci python-pytest-faulthandler python-represent dmalcolm llvm dmoluguw dogtag-pki pki-core dmsimard python-box python-django-health-check dmurphy18 salt dodji offlineimap dormouse python-libsass dreua pdfarranger dridi python-webcolors dshea python-polib dtardon libreoffice duffy inkscape duriantang bumpversion dwayne translate-toolkit dwmw2 qemu dwrobel flatcam echevemaster python-landslide python-scrapy edewata dogtag-pki pki-core eeickmeyer portmidi eerlands condor ehabkost qemu eharney python-cachez python-persist-queue python-retryz ekulik python-testing.postgresql ellert python-ipyparallel python-metakernel xrootd ellio167 lammps elwell pyephem erack libreoffice fab androguard artifacts cantoolz expliot hashid home-assistant-cli inception ioc-writer irclog2html past-time pdfarranger pdfposter pycolumnize pykka pylast pysubnettree python-apipkg python-astral python-betamax-matchers python-betamax-serializers python-colorlog python-convertdate python-crcelk python-dateparser python-dfdatetime python-dtfabric python-dulwich python-fiat python-filetype python-firkin python-glances-api python-hole python-instant python-javalang python-luftdaten python-mystrom python-netdata python-opendata-transport python-opensensemap-api python-paho-mqtt python-pkginfo python-play-scraper python-prawcore python-pypcapkit python-pytest-aiohttp python-pyvit python-queuelib python-rarfile python-requests-futures python-sybil python-tbtrim python-testfixtures python-ufl python-validators python-volkszaehler python-webthing-ws python-xmltodict rst2txt wafw00f xortool fabiand python-pexpect fantom poezio python-aiodns python-pycares python-slixmpp fcami freeipa-healthcheck ferdnyc gedit-plugin-editorconfig filabrazilska python-scales filiperosset python-myhdl firemanxbr python-pelican fjanus pyodbc frankcrawford pylibacl pyxattr rdiff-backup frantisekz mozjs68 rpmdeplint frixxon fontforge frostyx modulemd-tools prunerepo fschwarz pdfarranger python-ndg_httpsclient python-pdfrw python-pyrfc3339 python-tinycss2 gbcox picard yubikey-manager gbitzes gfal2-python gd samba giallu rdkit girst mopidy-mpd greghellings cinch python-plumbum grover python-simpleparse gsauthof python-asyncssh python-img2pdf python-inema python-zeep harald python-varlink hedayat starcal heffer borgmatic hguemar python-pyeclib hhorak PyGreSQL mysql-connector-python pyodbc hobbes1069 fail2ban python-requests-cache hony oval-graph hubbitus libcaca mysql-connector-python percol python-cmigemo hvad mysql-connector-python iboukris samba icon python-pyotp ignatenkobrain 0ad llvm python-gevent python-joblib python-mutagen python-oauth2 python-pexpect python-scikit-learn ihrachyshka python-jsonrpclib immanetize python-cached_property itamarjp openbabel python-dialog python-flask-gravatar python-flask-htmlmin python-flask-paranoid python-flask-security python-flask-sphinx-themes python-ndg_httpsclient python-pyrfc3339 ivazquez python-polib jakub llvm jamatos pygsl jankratochvil lldb jarrpa samba jbertozzi python-spdx python-spdx-lookup python-upt-cpan python-upt-fedora python-upt-pypi python-upt-rubygems upt jcapitao python-timeout-decorator jcaratzas python-more-itertools jchaloup dblatex jdekloe pyproj python-metar jdornak bumpversion mod_wsgi python-django python-django-tagging jdulaney python-networkmanager python-setuptools-lint jeckersb python-cachetools jfilak python-inotify jflory7 protonvpn-cli jforbes qemu jgu fail2ban inkscape python-rencode jhogarth python-acme python-certbot-apache python-junit_xml python-pyrfc3339 python-winrm jistone llvm llvm7.0 llvm9.0 jjames python-zodbpickle sympy jjelen tpm2-pkcs11 jkaluza mod_wsgi jkonecny python-pocketlint jlayton samba jmlich PyGreSQL gdal johnp pygobject3 jonny electrum python-btchip python-jsonrpclib python-libnacl python-libusb1 python-mnemonic python-pbkdf2 python-shamir-mnemonic python-trezor jortel python-suds jorti python-babelfish python-enzyme python-faker python-fuse python-guessit python-pysrt python-pytest-benchmark python-rebulk python-subliminal jorton mod_wsgi jpena python-django-formtools jruzicka crudini jsafrane yawn jsedlak python-aniso8601 jskarvad uhd jspaleta python-basemap python-xlib jstanek spec2scl jsteffan python-carbon python-watchdog jstephen samba jsynacek python-pycurl jtaylor python-idstools jujens python-CommonMark python-agate python-autobahn python-dbfread python-et_xmlfile python-htmlmin python-jinja2-cli python-leather python-pytest-mock python-pytest-watch python-recommonmark python-restructuredtext-lint python-snappy python-toml python-txaio python-watchdog python-wsaccel python3-pytest-asyncio junghans lammps jussilehtola OpenMolcas cppcheck gau2grid libxc openbabel sympy kad uwsgi kalev mozjs68 kdudka file python-pycurl kenhys sentencepiece kevin fontforge koji py-bcrypt pylibacl python-chai python-cloud-sptheme python-html5-parser python-hupper python-kitchen python-meld3 python-pygeoip python-pypng python-pytest-fixture-config python-pytest-shutil python-pytest-virtualenv python-sanction python-sieve pyxattr rdiff-backup kiilerix hgview mercurial tortoisehg kni python-pysignals kparal python-aniso8601 ktdreyer python-apipkg python-debrepo python-notario python-pecan-notario kumarpraveen python-django-registration kushal porcupine pycolumnize kushal124 python-docx kwizart gns3-gui gns3-net-converter gns3-server kwright dogtag-pki pki-core kyle llvm lbalhar python-pytest-faulthandler python-represent python-scales lbazan python-biopython lberk pcp pcp2pdf python-rmtest lead2gold python-apprise leamas python-xlwt lenkaseg cranc limb dolfin frescobaldi inkscape mpi4py pcapy py-bcrypt pybluez python-alsa python-basemap python-dateparser python-igraph python-pytest-vcr python3-poppler-qt5 pyusb solarwolf lkf legofy lkundrak inkscape python-scales qemu lmacken mod_wsgi python-simplemediawiki lorenzodalrio python-plumbum louizatakk poezio python-slixmpp lsedlar compose-utils lupinix ginga python-astropy-healpix python-astroquery python-astroscrappy python-ccdproc python-fitsio python-pyvo python-reproject python-scikit-learn macermak file maci python-apsw major python-editdistance python-neurodsp python-odml marcindulak python-ase python-idstools matt condor matyas condor mbaldessari pcp2pdf python-dpkt python-mutagen mbarnes commissaire-client python-etcd melmorabity python-iso-639 python-iso3166 mfabian nototools pyhunspell mgieseki cxxtest mgoodwin pcp python-rmtest mharmsen dogtag-pki pki-core mhjacks git-up pipx mich181189 python-twilio michich gajim python-precis_i18n mikem koji mikep python-intervaltree milleruntime thrift miminar yawn misc mgarepo mjakubicek python-dialog mjg dblatex portmidi mkosek freeipa-healthcheck mkrizek python-mongoquery mlombard python-simpleparse mmahut gdal mmarusak python-testing.postgresql moezroy python-construct python-mutagen python-polib python-xlwt mooninite wine-mono mrunge mod_wsgi nodejs python-autopep8 python-django python-django-contact-form python-django-formtools python-django-reversion python-django-tagging python-django-tastypie python-fasteners python-pelican python-webpy python-xvfbwrapper mschorm mysql-connector-python msekleta python-pycurl msimacek python-i3ipc mstuchli pipsi msuchy python-testing.postgresql musuruan ogr2osm mvadkert rpmdeplint nacho pygobject3 nathans pcp python-rmtest nb python-acme python-certbot-apache nbecker mercurial tortoisehg ndipanov python-autopep8 neteler gdal nforro python-m2r ngompa mgarepo nkorde opae nonamedotc python-nmrglue python-rope spyder noodles python-dialog python-ndg_httpsclient python-pyrfc3339 notting offlineimap nphilipp python-rpmautospec rpmspectool nucleo gns3-server oanson python-jsonmodels obnox samba odubaj PyGreSQL file ohaessler picard oliver gdal ondrejj python-sieve orion fail2ban gdal python-conda-package-handling python-enthought-sphinx-theme python-fido2 python-gevent python-pycosat python-rencode python-sphinxcontrib-issuetracker python-xlib sympy thrift orphan pyephem pabelanger python-statsd pali gdal panovotn PyGreSQL patches nodejs python-rencode pbrady crudini pbrobinson tpm2-pkcs11 pcpa 0ad python-ipykernel python-pathlib2 pcreech17 python-pkginfo perex python-alsa peter pylast petersen llvm7.0 translate-toolkit pfrields python-pulsectl phracek modtools pingou R2spec python-GeoIP python-chai python-contextlib2 python-igraph python-kitchen python-watchdog piotrp nodejs python-carbon python-django-tagging pjp python-oauth2 python-unidecode pkajaba PyGreSQL pkubat PyGreSQL pnemade fontdump fontforge fonttools python-fs potty python-pycha python-simplemediawiki python-xlib praiskup PyGreSQL gdal python-inotify_simple pspacek python-lmdb pstodulk mercurial puiterwijk koji pviktori py3c pvoborni freeipa-healthcheck pwalter 0ad scribus pwouters python-xml2rfc pwu nototools quintela qemu qulogic python-click-plugins python-descartes python-geopandas python-heapdict python-kiwisolver python-octave-kernel python-partd python-pep8-naming python-pytest-tornado python-tblib python-zict radez python-pexpect ralph datanommer httpie python-GeoIP python-chai python-cloud-sptheme python-contextlib2 python-kitchen python-pygeoip python-pypng python-sanction python-sieve python-simplemediawiki python-virtualenv-clone python-xmltodict raphgro python-dialog python-jep python-jnius python-pvc rathann openbabel python-GridDataFormats python-OBD python-biopython python-colorspacious python-fypp python-gsd python-kaitaistruct python-mmtf python-publicsuffix2 python-tempdir python-xlwt python-zstandard solaar rcritten freeipa-healthcheck python-kerberos rdieter python-mwclient rdopiera python-django rebus officeparser python-oletools rharwood python-kdcproxy richardfearn solaar rickardlindberg python-humblewx rjones qemu rmarko python-flask-rstpages rmattes python-bloom python-rosdep robert python-oletools python-pcodedmp rohanpm python-edgegrid python-fastpurge python-more-executors sagitter COPASI ProDy libCombine petsc petsc4py python-biopython python-giacpy python-periodictable python-reportlab seqan spglib salimma python-django python-psutil sbergmann libreoffice schlupov copr-messaging scottt llvm sergesanspaille lldb llvm llvm7.0 llvm9.0 offlineimap xtensor-python sergiomb PySolFC python-GeoIP python-libnacl sergiopr APLpy python-arviz python-astroplan python-dill python-emcee python-joblib python-pandas-datareader python-patsy python-pdfrw python-photutils python-pytest-astropy-header python-scikit-learn python-statsmodels sgallagh nodejs python-django sgrubb cppcheck sharkcz python-openoffice python-proteus python-pycha python-relatorio python-sql scribus tryton trytond trytond-account trytond-account-be trytond-account-de-skr03 trytond-account-invoice trytond-account-invoice-history trytond-account-invoice-line-standalone trytond-account-product trytond-account-statement trytond-account-stock-anglo-saxon trytond-account-stock-continental trytond-analytic-account trytond-analytic-invoice trytond-analytic-purchase trytond-analytic-sale trytond-company trytond-company-work-time trytond-country trytond-currency trytond-dashboard trytond-google-maps trytond-ldap-authentication trytond-party trytond-party-siret trytond-product trytond-product-cost-fifo trytond-product-cost-history trytond-product-price-list trytond-project trytond-project-plan trytond-project-revenue trytond-purchase trytond-purchase-invoice-line-standalone trytond-sale trytond-sale-opportunity trytond-sale-price-list trytond-stock trytond-stock-forecast trytond-stock-inventory-location trytond-stock-location-sequence trytond-stock-product-location trytond-stock-supply trytond-stock-supply-day trytond-timesheet shlomif PySolFC siddharths lldb llvm simo python-kerberos samba simonm xrootd sjenning pyscard yubikey-manager skisela python-ansicolors skottler python-gevent skytux APLpy slaanesh libcaca python-pdfrw smani gdal smilner commissaire-client python-etcd somlo python-logzero python-migen spot python-oauth2 texlive-base winpdb stevetraylen condor h5py python-django-tastypie python-inotify python-meld3 stomppy stingray pyserial suanand python-polib python-tinydb translate-toolkit sundaram python-dialog python-oauth2 python-unidecode suve copydeps dnstwist python-ssdeep svashisht file python-pycurl swt2c congruity python-pexpect python-pypubsub python-pytest-forked python-pytest-timeout python-pytest-xdist python-suds szpak pylibacl pyxattr tachoknight swift-lang tadej python-pydocstyle python-virtualenv-clone tagoh fonttools tdecacqu python-statsd terjeros h5py python-acoustid python-audioread python-construct python-inotify teuf offlineimap thias libcaca python-metar thm python-apipkg python-markdown2 thofmann btrfs-sxbackup dot2tex librealsense python-rosdep shyaml thozza spyder tibbs solaar till pyhunspell timj rpl tjikkun python-contextlib2 tnorth ViTables python-blosc python-tables tohojo flent tomh pyosmium python-mapnik tomspur mpi4py python-pexpect totol python-GeoIP python-lark-parser python-xvfbwrapper tripledes scribus trix opae tsao python-meld3 tstclair condor tstellar lldb llvm llvm7.0 llvm9.0 ttheisen condor ttomecek modtools python-urwidtrees ttrinks ansible-review turboturtle sos-collector tuxbrewr python-mwclient twaugh python-journal-brief twoerner freeipa-healthcheck uggla python-Pyped python-formats python-minibelt python-tortilla vakwetu dogtag-pki pki-core valtri condor vcrhonek yawn vkrizan python-djangoql vmihalko file vmojzis sepolicy_analysis volter gdal python-Rtree vtrefny python-pocketlint wakko666 python-cookiecutter python-jinja2-time python-poyo python-tree-format walters pygobject3 williamjmorenor legofy xavierb portmidi python-bigsuds xenithorb python-btchip xvitaly libolm python-emoji python-node-semver python-patch-ng python-pytelegrambotapi python-wloc zaitcev python-pyeclib zbyszek ViTables dolfin moose python-asttokens python-blosc python-css-parser python-decopatch python-dialog python-dijitso python-dukpy python-ffc python-fisx python-makefun python-mdp python-music21 python-pysb python-pytest-cases python-pytest-harvest python-pytest-steps python-soupsieve python-tables zvetlik nodejs
On 6/23/20 12:26 PM, Tomas Hrnciar wrote:
<snip>
We would like to kindly ask you to add explicit BuildRequires for python3-setuptools to packages where setuptools is used.
<snip>
nonamedotc python-nmrglue python-rope spyder
<snip>
I have added buildrequires on setuptools for these three packages.
On 6/23/20 9:26 AM, Tomas Hrnciar wrote:
Hello everyone,
there are plenty of Python packages in Fedora currently using setuptools at buildtime but not all of them are BuildRequiring it explicitly. This only works because python3-devel (transitively) depends on python3-setuptools.
We would like to kindly ask you to add explicit BuildRequires for python3-setuptools to packages where setuptools is used. It will help us with testing new versions of setuptools in the future or with decoupling Python and setuptools. Today, if we want to know if a package is using setuptools,we have to do `fedpkgprep` and use grep to search for setuptools. Using a repoquery is much more convenient.
...
salimma python-django python-psutil
Done (for Rawhide). For python-psutil I'm following the other pattern in the spec and using python%{python3_pkgversion}-setuptools, but this should resolve to python3-setuptools when you use repoquery.
Cheers,
On 23. 06. 20 18:26, Tomas Hrnciar wrote:
churchyard python-django python-ipykernel python-more-itertools python-ndg_httpsclient thonny
All fixed at least in git. The changes should be visible in repoquery upon the next rebuild.
On Tue, 23 Jun 2020, Tomas Hrnciar wrote:
swt2c congruity python-pexpect python-pypubsub python-pytest-forked python-pytest-timeout python-pytest-xdist python-suds
All fixed in rawhide except for python-pexpect, which doesn't actually use setuptools. Strangely, it only uses it when setup.py is called with a 'bdist_wheel' argument.
Scott
On Tue, Jun 23, 2020 at 06:26:23PM +0200, Tomas Hrnciar wrote:
Hello everyone,
there are plenty of Python packages in Fedora currently using setuptools at buildtime but not all of them are BuildRequiring it explicitly. This only works because python3-devel (transitively) depends on python3-setuptools.
We would like to kindly ask you to add explicit BuildRequires for python3-setuptools to packages where setuptools is used. It will help us with testing new versions of setuptools in the future or with decoupling Python and setuptools. Today, if we want to know if a package is using setuptools, we have to do `fedpkg prep` and use grep to search for setuptools. Using a repoquery is much more convenient.
Several packages can successfully build either with or without setuptools (they use try-except import and fallback to distutils from the standard library). Such packages are especially dangerous when not BuildRequiring setuptools -- they can produce different results depending on the presence of setuptools: either an .egg-info metadata directory (w/setuptools) or .egg-info text file (w/distutils). RPM has troubles when upgrading directories to files [1].
[1] https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/packaging-guidelines/Directory_Replacem...
According to our grep based query on Fedora Rawhide, there are 621 known packages using setuptools without BuildRequiring it at this point:
Thank you very much for your help with this.
On behalf of python-setuptools maintainers, Tomáš Hrnčiar
[snip...]
flawfinder athoscr
Fixed in rawhide
[snip...]
python-devel@lists.fedoraproject.org
-
Athos Ribeiro -
Felix Schwarz -
José Abílio Matos -
Michel Alexandre Salim -
Miro Hrončok -
Mukundan Ragavan -
Scott Talbert -
Tomas Hrnciar