Rust Stack Spring Cleaning (in Winter)

[Fabio Valentini]

Hello Rust packagers,

(I'm sending this email to the devel and rust lists, and I've added all directly
affected package maintainers in Bcc - because adding them all to the "To" or
"CC" fields would make the lists reject this message, I believe.)

I have been working on and preparing some more clean-ups in the Rust stack, and
I came across a large-ish number of Rust packages that were imported to Fedora,
but the recommended "initial setup" for them was never finished.

I have started by adding them all "rust-*" packages to koschei, which makes it
way easier for me to see at a glance whether there are any broken packages in
our Rust stack at any point in time.

I will also make sure all those packages are correctly set up with anitya /
release-monitoring.org, so that we actually get notifications for new versions
of all those crate packages.

Additionally, I would ask of all of you to make sure all your packages have been
added to the @rust-sig group on src.fedoraproject.org (at least with "commit"
access). Without that, it makes it very hard for us to keep the Rust stack
up-to-date and in working order, because the "rust-sig" list / bugzilla account
does not get CC'd on new bugs that way, and your bugs do not show up in our
BugZilla queries.

For example, I have been working on packaging and updating the RustCrypto
stack of crates, and found that most of the already existing
(security-sensitive!) crates are not "completely" set up, and are now out of
date, just because I didn't even know about those packages (and some were also
not set up with release-monitoring.org).

In the interest of keeping the Rust stack in Fedora in a good state, please
add "@rust-sig" group to all you Rust packages on src.fedoraproject.org, unless
there is a very good reason not to do so (and if that is the case for a
particular package in this list, I'd be interested in knowing the reason, as
well).

If you want a scripted way of adding "@rust-sig" group to many packages, you
can generate an API token on src.fedoraproject.org (with "Modify an existing
project") access level, and use the simple Python script from this GitHub gist:

https://gist.github.com/decathorpe/9d128982cb00e2d345d9e397372538ec

Below is the list of "incompletely set-up" packages, in alphabetic order, and
at the bottom, there is a list of packages per affected package maintainer.

Thanks,
Fabio

===

- rust-arrayvec0.5: eclipseo
- rust-asn1: cheimes
- rust-asn1_derive: cheimes
- rust-assert-impl: dcavalca
- rust-aws-nitro-enclaves-cose: pbrobinson
- rust-benfred-read-process-memory: dcavalca
- rust-biscuit: orphan
- rust-bitfield: ignatenkobrain
- rust-block-cipher: ignatenkobrain
- rust-blsctl: javierm
- rust-btrd: dcavalca
- rust-bytelines: ignatenkobrain
- rust-clap_generate: eclipseo
- rust-clap_generate_fig: eclipseo
- rust-clircle: eclipseo
- rust-combine: dcavalca
- rust-console0.13: ignatenkobrain
- rust-cryptoki: pbrobinson
- rust-cryptoki-sys: pbrobinson
- rust-cty: nickblack
- rust-dbus-codegen: pbrobinson
- rust-dbus-crossroads: pbrobinson
- rust-derivative: pbrobinson
- rust-directories-next: jbtrystram
- rust-dirs2: ignatenkobrain
- rust-elf: dcavalca
- rust-enumflags2: ignatenkobrain, pbrobinson
- rust-env_proxy: dcavalca
- rust-epoll: slp
- rust-event-listener: dcavalca
- rust-fasteval: zbyszek
- rust-hostname-validator: ignatenkobrain
- rust-inferno: dcavalca
- rust-itertools0.9: ignatenkobrain
- rust-josekit: pbrobinson
- rust-js-sys: pbrobinson
- rust-keccak: pbrobinson
- rust-log-panics: salimma
- rust-mbox: ignatenkobrain, pbrobinson
- rust-navi: jbtrystram
- rust-netlink-packet-core: cathay4t, ffmancera
- rust-netlink-packet-route: cathay4t, ffmancera
- rust-netlink-packet-utils: cathay4t, ffmancera
- rust-netlink-proto: cathay4t, ffmancera
- rust-netlink-sys: cathay4t, ffmancera
- rust-num-format: dcavalca
- rust-oauth2: ctron, jbtrystram
- rust-oid: pbrobinson
- rust-openat-ext: walters
- rust-pam-sys: eneville
- rust-parsec-client: pbrobinson
- rust-parsec-interface: pbrobinson
- rust-picky-asn1: pbrobinson
- rust-picky-asn1-der: pbrobinson
- rust-picky-asn1-x509: pbrobinson
- rust-psa-crypto: pbrobinson
- rust-pkcs11: pbrobinson
- rust-pleaser: eneville
- rust-process_control: atim, petersen
- rust-proc-maps: dcavalca
- rust-prost: pbrobinson
- rust-prost-build: pbrobinson
- rust-prost-derive: pbrobinson
- rust-prost-types: pbrobinson
- rust-psa-crypto-sys: pbrobinson
- rust-qstring: ctron, jbtrystram
- rust-rand0.7: ignatenkobrain
- rust-rand_chacha0.2: ignatenkobrain
- rust-rand_core0.5: ignatenkobrain
- rust-rand_pcg0.2: ignatenkobrain
- rust-rbspy-ruby-structs: dcavalca
- rust-rbspy-testdata: dcavalca
- rust-read-process-memory: dcavalca
- rust-remoteprocess: dcavalca
- rust-rsa: pbrobinson
- rust-rtnetlink: cathay4t, ffmancera
- rust-sd-notify: pbrobinson
- rust-secrecy: pbrobinson
- rust-serde_with: pbrobinson
- rust-sha3: pbrobinson
- rust-shadow-rs: atim
- rust-shellwords: jbtrystram
- rust-signal-hook-mio: dcavalca
- rust-signature: orphan
- rust-simple_asn1: pbrobinson
- rust-stratisd_proc_macros: jbaublitz
- rust-str_stack: dcavalca
- rust-subprocess: dcavalca
- rust-syslog: eneville
- rust-tabular: jbtrystram
- rust-textwrap0.11: ignatenkobrain
- rust-textwrap0.12: ignatenkobrain
- rust-thread-tree: dcavalca
- rust-toml_edit: dcavalca
- rust-tss-esapi-sys: pbrobinson
- rust-universal-hash: pbrobinson
- rust-version: pbrobinson
- rust-versions: atim
- rust-version-sync0.8: ignatenkobrain
- rust-virtio-bindings: slp
- rust-vm-memory: slp
- rust-vmm-sys-util: slp
- rust-vte_generate_state_changes: ignatenkobrain
- rust-webbrowser: ctron, jbtrystram
- rust-zmq: ueno

Lists by maintainer:

- atim (3): rust-process_control, rust-shadow-rs, rust-versions

- cathay4t (6): rust-netlink-packet-core, rust-netlink-packet-route,
rust-netlink-packet-utils, rust-netlink-proto, rust-netlink-sys,
rust-rtnetlink

- cheimes (2): rust-asn1, rust-asn1_derive

- ctron (3): rust-oauth2, rust-qstring, rust-webbrowser

- dcavalca (19): rust-assert-impl, rust-benfred-read-process-memory,
rust-btrd, rust-combine, rust-elf, rust-env_proxy,
rust-event-listener, rust-inferno, rust-num-format, rust-proc-maps,
rust-rbspy-ruby-structs, rust-rbspy-testdata,
rust-read-process-memory, rust-remoteprocess, rust-signal-hook-mio,
rust-str_stack, rust-subprocess, rust-thread-tree, rust-toml_edit

- eclipseo (4): rust-arrayvec0.5, rust-clap_generate,
rust-clap_generate_fig, rust-clircle

- eneville (3): rust-pam-sys, rust-pleaser, rust-syslog

- ffmancera (6): rust-netlink-packet-core, rust-netlink-packet-route,
rust-netlink-packet-utils, rust-netlink-proto, rust-netlink-sys,
rust-rtnetlink

- ignatenkobrain (17): rust-bitfield, rust-block-cipher,
rust-bytelines, rust-console0.13, rust-dirs2, rust-enumflags2,
rust-hostname-validator, rust-itertools0.9, rust-mbox, rust-rand0.7,
rust-rand_chacha0.2, rust-rand_core0.5, rust-rand_pcg0.2,
rust-textwrap0.11, rust-textwrap0.12, rust-version-sync0.8,
rust-vte_generate_state_changes

- javierm (1): rust-blsctl

- jbaublitz (1): rust-stratisd_proc_macros

- jbtrystram (7): rust-directories-next, rust-navi, rust-oauth2,
rust-qstring, rust-shellwords, rust-tabular, rust-webbrowser

- nickblack (1): rust-cty

- orphan (2): rust-biscuit, rust-signature

- pbrobinson (33): rust-aws-nitro-enclaves-cose, rust-cryptoki,
rust-cryptoki-sys, rust-dbus-codegen, rust-dbus-crossroads,
rust-derivative, rust-enumflags2, rust-josekit, rust-js-sys,
rust-keccak, rust-mbox, rust-oid, rust-parsec-client,
rust-parsec-interface, rust-picky-asn1, rust-picky-asn1-der,
rust-picky-asn1-x509, rust-psa-crypto, rust-pkcs11, rust-prost,
rust-prost-build, rust-prost-derive, rust-prost-types,
rust-psa-crypto-sys, rust-rsa, rust-sd-notify, rust-secrecy,
rust-serde_with, rust-sha3, rust-simple_asn1, rust-tss-esapi-sys,
rust-universal-hash, rust-version

- petersen (1): rust-process_control

- salimma (1): rust-log-panics

- slp (4): rust-epoll, rust-virtio-bindings, rust-vm-memory, rust-vmm-sys-util

- ueno (1): rust-zmq

- walters (1): rust-openat-ext

- zbyszek (1): rust-fasteval

[Josh Stone]

Thank you for working on this, Fabio!

On Mon, Dec 20, 2021 at 6:32 AM Fabio Valentini <decathorpe(a)gmail.com&gt;
wrote:

>  Hello Rust packagers,
>
>  (I'm sending this email to the devel and rust lists, and I've added all
>  directly
>  affected package maintainers in Bcc - because adding them all to the "To"
>  or
>  "CC" fields would make the lists reject this message, I believe.)
>
>  I have been working on and preparing some more clean-ups in the Rust
>  stack, and
>  I came across a large-ish number of Rust packages that were imported to
>  Fedora,
>  but the recommended "initial setup" for them was never finished.
>
>  I have started by adding them all "rust-*" packages to koschei, which
>  makes it
>  way easier for me to see at a glance whether there are any broken packages
>  in
>  our Rust stack at any point in time.
>
>  I will also make sure all those packages are correctly set up with anitya /
>  release-monitoring.org, so that we actually get notifications for new
>  versions
>  of all those crate packages.
>
>  Additionally, I would ask of all of you to make sure all your packages
>  have been
>  added to the @rust-sig group on src.fedoraproject.org (at least with
>  "commit"
>  access). Without that, it makes it very hard for us to keep the Rust stack
>  up-to-date and in working order, because the "rust-sig" list / bugzilla
>  account
>  does not get CC'd on new bugs that way, and your bugs do not show up in our
>  BugZilla queries.
>
>  For example, I have been working on packaging and updating the RustCrypto
>  stack of crates, and found that most of the already existing
>  (security-sensitive!) crates are not "completely" set up, and are now out
>  of
>  date, just because I didn't even know about those packages (and some were
>  also
>  not set up with release-monitoring.org).
>
>  In the interest of keeping the Rust stack in Fedora in a good state, please
>  add "@rust-sig" group to all you Rust packages on src.fedoraproject.org,
>  unless
>  there is a very good reason not to do so (and if that is the case for a
>  particular package in this list, I'd be interested in knowing the reason,
>  as
>  well).
>
>  If you want a scripted way of adding "@rust-sig" group to many packages,
>  you
>  can generate an API token on src.fedoraproject.org (with "Modify an
>  existing
>  project") access level, and use the simple Python script from this GitHub
>  gist:
>
>  https://gist.github.com/decathorpe/9d128982cb00e2d345d9e397372538ec
>
>  Below is the list of "incompletely set-up" packages, in alphabetic order,
>  and
>  at the bottom, there is a list of packages per affected package maintainer.
>
>  Thanks,
>  Fabio
>
>  ===
>
>  - rust-arrayvec0.5: eclipseo
>  - rust-asn1: cheimes
>  - rust-asn1_derive: cheimes
>  - rust-assert-impl: dcavalca
>  - rust-aws-nitro-enclaves-cose: pbrobinson
>  - rust-benfred-read-process-memory: dcavalca
>  - rust-biscuit: orphan
>  - rust-bitfield: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-block-cipher: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-blsctl: javierm
>  - rust-btrd: dcavalca
>  - rust-bytelines: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-clap_generate: eclipseo
>  - rust-clap_generate_fig: eclipseo
>  - rust-clircle: eclipseo
>  - rust-combine: dcavalca
>  - rust-console0.13: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-cryptoki: pbrobinson
>  - rust-cryptoki-sys: pbrobinson
>  - rust-cty: nickblack
>  - rust-dbus-codegen: pbrobinson
>  - rust-dbus-crossroads: pbrobinson
>  - rust-derivative: pbrobinson
>  - rust-directories-next: jbtrystram
>  - rust-dirs2: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-elf: dcavalca
>  - rust-enumflags2: ignatenkobrain, pbrobinson
>  - rust-env_proxy: dcavalca
>  - rust-epoll: slp
>  - rust-event-listener: dcavalca
>  - rust-fasteval: zbyszek
>  - rust-hostname-validator: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-inferno: dcavalca
>  - rust-itertools0.9: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-josekit: pbrobinson
>  - rust-js-sys: pbrobinson
>  - rust-keccak: pbrobinson
>  - rust-log-panics: salimma
>  - rust-mbox: ignatenkobrain, pbrobinson
>  - rust-navi: jbtrystram
>  - rust-netlink-packet-core: cathay4t, ffmancera
>  - rust-netlink-packet-route: cathay4t, ffmancera
>  - rust-netlink-packet-utils: cathay4t, ffmancera
>  - rust-netlink-proto: cathay4t, ffmancera
>  - rust-netlink-sys: cathay4t, ffmancera
>  - rust-num-format: dcavalca
>  - rust-oauth2: ctron, jbtrystram
>  - rust-oid: pbrobinson
>  - rust-openat-ext: walters
>  - rust-pam-sys: eneville
>  - rust-parsec-client: pbrobinson
>  - rust-parsec-interface: pbrobinson
>  - rust-picky-asn1: pbrobinson
>  - rust-picky-asn1-der: pbrobinson
>  - rust-picky-asn1-x509: pbrobinson
>  - rust-psa-crypto: pbrobinson
>  - rust-pkcs11: pbrobinson
>  - rust-pleaser: eneville
>  - rust-process_control: atim, petersen
>  - rust-proc-maps: dcavalca
>  - rust-prost: pbrobinson
>  - rust-prost-build: pbrobinson
>  - rust-prost-derive: pbrobinson
>  - rust-prost-types: pbrobinson
>  - rust-psa-crypto-sys: pbrobinson
>  - rust-qstring: ctron, jbtrystram
>  - rust-rand0.7: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-rand_chacha0.2: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-rand_core0.5: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-rand_pcg0.2: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-rbspy-ruby-structs: dcavalca
>  - rust-rbspy-testdata: dcavalca
>  - rust-read-process-memory: dcavalca
>  - rust-remoteprocess: dcavalca
>  - rust-rsa: pbrobinson
>  - rust-rtnetlink: cathay4t, ffmancera
>  - rust-sd-notify: pbrobinson
>  - rust-secrecy: pbrobinson
>  - rust-serde_with: pbrobinson
>  - rust-sha3: pbrobinson
>  - rust-shadow-rs: atim
>  - rust-shellwords: jbtrystram
>  - rust-signal-hook-mio: dcavalca
>  - rust-signature: orphan
>  - rust-simple_asn1: pbrobinson
>  - rust-stratisd_proc_macros: jbaublitz
>  - rust-str_stack: dcavalca
>  - rust-subprocess: dcavalca
>  - rust-syslog: eneville
>  - rust-tabular: jbtrystram
>  - rust-textwrap0.11: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-textwrap0.12: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-thread-tree: dcavalca
>  - rust-toml_edit: dcavalca
>  - rust-tss-esapi-sys: pbrobinson
>  - rust-universal-hash: pbrobinson
>  - rust-version: pbrobinson
>  - rust-versions: atim
>  - rust-version-sync0.8: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-virtio-bindings: slp
>  - rust-vm-memory: slp
>  - rust-vmm-sys-util: slp
>  - rust-vte_generate_state_changes: ignatenkobrain
>  - rust-webbrowser: ctron, jbtrystram
>  - rust-zmq: ueno
>
>  Lists by maintainer:
>
>  - atim (3): rust-process_control, rust-shadow-rs, rust-versions
>
>  - cathay4t (6): rust-netlink-packet-core, rust-netlink-packet-route,
>  rust-netlink-packet-utils, rust-netlink-proto, rust-netlink-sys,
>  rust-rtnetlink
>
>  - cheimes (2): rust-asn1, rust-asn1_derive
>
>  - ctron (3): rust-oauth2, rust-qstring, rust-webbrowser
>
>  - dcavalca (19): rust-assert-impl, rust-benfred-read-process-memory,
>  rust-btrd, rust-combine, rust-elf, rust-env_proxy,
>  rust-event-listener, rust-inferno, rust-num-format, rust-proc-maps,
>  rust-rbspy-ruby-structs, rust-rbspy-testdata,
>  rust-read-process-memory, rust-remoteprocess, rust-signal-hook-mio,
>  rust-str_stack, rust-subprocess, rust-thread-tree, rust-toml_edit
>
>  - eclipseo (4): rust-arrayvec0.5, rust-clap_generate,
>  rust-clap_generate_fig, rust-clircle
>
>  - eneville (3): rust-pam-sys, rust-pleaser, rust-syslog
>
>  - ffmancera (6): rust-netlink-packet-core, rust-netlink-packet-route,
>  rust-netlink-packet-utils, rust-netlink-proto, rust-netlink-sys,
>  rust-rtnetlink
>
>  - ignatenkobrain (17): rust-bitfield, rust-block-cipher,
>  rust-bytelines, rust-console0.13, rust-dirs2, rust-enumflags2,
>  rust-hostname-validator, rust-itertools0.9, rust-mbox, rust-rand0.7,
>  rust-rand_chacha0.2, rust-rand_core0.5, rust-rand_pcg0.2,
>  rust-textwrap0.11, rust-textwrap0.12, rust-version-sync0.8,
>  rust-vte_generate_state_changes
>
>  - javierm (1): rust-blsctl
>
>  - jbaublitz (1): rust-stratisd_proc_macros
>
>  - jbtrystram (7): rust-directories-next, rust-navi, rust-oauth2,
>  rust-qstring, rust-shellwords, rust-tabular, rust-webbrowser
>
>  - nickblack (1): rust-cty
>
>  - orphan (2): rust-biscuit, rust-signature
>
>  - pbrobinson (33): rust-aws-nitro-enclaves-cose, rust-cryptoki,
>  rust-cryptoki-sys, rust-dbus-codegen, rust-dbus-crossroads,
>  rust-derivative, rust-enumflags2, rust-josekit, rust-js-sys,
>  rust-keccak, rust-mbox, rust-oid, rust-parsec-client,
>  rust-parsec-interface, rust-picky-asn1, rust-picky-asn1-der,
>  rust-picky-asn1-x509, rust-psa-crypto, rust-pkcs11, rust-prost,
>  rust-prost-build, rust-prost-derive, rust-prost-types,
>  rust-psa-crypto-sys, rust-rsa, rust-sd-notify, rust-secrecy,
>  rust-serde_with, rust-sha3, rust-simple_asn1, rust-tss-esapi-sys,
>  rust-universal-hash, rust-version
>
>  - petersen (1): rust-process_control
>
>  - salimma (1): rust-log-panics
>
>  - slp (4): rust-epoll, rust-virtio-bindings, rust-vm-memory,
>  rust-vmm-sys-util
>
>  - ueno (1): rust-zmq
>
>  - walters (1): rust-openat-ext
>
>  - zbyszek (1): rust-fasteval
>  _______________________________________________
>  devel mailing list -- devel(a)lists.fedoraproject.org
>  To unsubscribe send an email to devel-leave(a)lists.fedoraproject.org
>  Fedora Code of Conduct:
>  https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/
>  List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines
>  List Archives:
>  https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/[e-mail]
>  Do not reply to spam on the list, report it:
>  https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure
>

[Michel Alexandre Salim]

On Mon, Dec 20, 2021 at 03:31:21PM +0100, Fabio Valentini wrote:
>  In the interest of keeping the Rust stack in Fedora in a good state,
> please
>  add "@rust-sig" group to all you Rust packages on src.fedoraproject.org,
> unless
>  there is a very good reason not to do so (and if that is the case for a
>  particular package in this list, I'd be interested in knowing the reason, as
>  well).
>  
>  - salimma (1): rust-log-panics
>   
Done. Sorry for the delay, I was running behind on my mailing lists
during the holidays.

One question: I don't seem to be able to register a package into the
Koschei rust-sig group, so for new packages I'm adding, they are
currently ungrouped.

Who has access to this? I'm already a member of rust-sig in FAS.

Thanks,

-- 
Michel Alexandre Salim
profile: https://keyoxide.org/[e-mail]