On Sat, 02 Aug 2014 02:59:20 +0200 Reindl Harald wrote:
> Out of curiosity, what exactly do "discontinue" mean
here? Retire
> it from released and still supported Fedora versions, or only from
> future (21+)? I know packages get removed from EPEL, I'm not sure
> if / how often that happens in Fedora
...
* you can't remove them from released ISO's
There is actually a difference to EPEL I haven't realized before.
Fedora uses separate release and updates repos, EPEL has single
repository. I do not know how/if Fedora removals from the release
repos are done.
the real critical question in case of abandoned packages which stay
unmaintained is does it a user typing "yum install" and get the
impression it's maintained a favor or better not offer it in the
repos so new users not start build infrastructure around it with
no future and realize that later
Removal of unmaintained packages is of benefit to users not using the
component now who may try to yum install it in the future.
I believe more important question is if removal is sufficient
"notification" to existing users. Arguably, it is better than keeping
packages in repos and unmaintained...
Anyway, such removals seem much harder to defend in case of short life
distribution like Fedora.
--
Tomas Hoger / Red Hat Product Security