Still unconfined?

[Jimmy]

Hi!

Im trying to learn SELinux from bottom up, but having some fundamental 
issues regarding the basics.
Im trying to load the mozilla.pp module in targeted, which works fine. I 
set the correct contexts with restorecon on firefox-bin. But when i run 
the binary it stills runs in unconfined_t when looking at running 
processes (ps auxZ).
Ivé tried to compile it myself from different sources, and load it, but 
get the same results all the time. Then i tried with netutils.pp and 
discovered the same problem witrh ping.

Why doesnt firefox get transfered to the $1_mozilla_t domain??? I know 
im making some really fundamental mistake somewhere, but i cant find out 
what it is!

With best regards / Tomten

[Stephen Smalley]

On Tue, 2006-11-28 at 19:36 +0100, Jimmy wrote:
>  Hi!
>  
>  Im trying to learn SELinux from bottom up, but having some fundamental 
>  issues regarding the basics.
>  Im trying to load the mozilla.pp module in targeted, which works fine. I 
>  set the correct contexts with restorecon on firefox-bin. But when i run 
>  the binary it stills runs in unconfined_t when looking at running 
>  processes (ps auxZ).
>  Ivé tried to compile it myself from different sources, and load it, but 
>  get the same results all the time. Then i tried with netutils.pp and 
>  discovered the same problem witrh ping.
>  
>  Why doesnt firefox get transfered to the $1_mozilla_t domain??? I know 
>  im making some really fundamental mistake somewhere, but i cant find out 
>  what it is! 
If mozilla's domain was a "simple" domain, then mozilla.pp would just
contain its definition, and you would still need to set up a transition
from unconfined_t to mozilla's domain, likely by calling an interface
defined by mozilla.if from unconfined.te.   But mozilla's domain is
templated for instantiation once per user role, and targeted policy has
no notion of user roles or domains, mozilla.pp doesn't even contain the
actual domain definition, just a few type declarations for file types
used for mozilla - the real domain definition happens as a result of
template expansion for each user role.

In short, mozilla's policy was written for the strict policy.  You'd
have to do some work to instantiate it for unconfined in targeted and
ensure that none of its assumptions are broken there, and your ability
to limit what it can do will be severely constrained with targeted
policy.

-- 
Stephen Smalley
National Security Agency

[Daniel J Walsh]

Jimmy wrote:
>  Hi!
>
>  Im trying to learn SELinux from bottom up, but having some fundamental 
>  issues regarding the basics.
>  Im trying to load the mozilla.pp module in targeted, which works fine. 
>  I set the correct contexts with restorecon on firefox-bin. But when i 
>  run the binary it stills runs in unconfined_t when looking at running 
>  processes (ps auxZ).
>  Ivé tried to compile it myself from different sources, and load it, 
>  but get the same results all the time. Then i tried with netutils.pp 
>  and discovered the same problem witrh ping.
>
>  Why doesnt firefox get transfered to the $1_mozilla_t domain??? I know 
>  im making some really fundamental mistake somewhere, but i cant find 
>  out what it is!
>
>  With best regards / Tomten
>
>  -- 
>  fedora-selinux-list mailing list
>  fedora-selinux-list(a)redhat.com
>  https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-selinux-list 
You need to write a
transition rule from unconfined_t to mozilla_t

Something like

mozilla_per_role_template(user, unconfined_t, system_r)


But there is a bug in policy right now

    gen_require(`
        type mozilla_exec_t;
        type mozilla_conf_t;
    ')

Needs to be added to the mozilla_per_role_template interface definition.

[Daniel J Walsh]

Daniel J Walsh wrote:
>  Jimmy wrote:
> > Hi!
> >
> > Im trying to learn SELinux from bottom up, but having some 
> > fundamental issues regarding the basics.
> > Im trying to load the mozilla.pp module in targeted, which works 
> > fine. I set the correct contexts with restorecon on firefox-bin. But 
> > when i run the binary it stills runs in unconfined_t when looking at 
> > running processes (ps auxZ).
> > Ivé tried to compile it myself from different sources, and load it, 
> > but get the same results all the time. Then i tried with netutils.pp 
> > and discovered the same problem witrh ping.
> >
> > Why doesnt firefox get transfered to the $1_mozilla_t domain??? I 
> > know im making some really fundamental mistake somewhere, but i cant 
> > find out what it is!
> >
> > With best regards / Tomten
> >
> > -- 
> > fedora-selinux-list mailing list
> > fedora-selinux-list(a)redhat.com
> > https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-selinux-list
>  You need to write a transition rule from unconfined_t to mozilla_t
>
>  Something like
>
>  mozilla_per_role_template(user, unconfined_t, system_r)
>
>
>  But there is a bug in policy right now
>
>     gen_require(`
>         type mozilla_exec_t;
>         type mozilla_conf_t;
>     ')
>
>  Needs to be added to the mozilla_per_role_template interface definition.
>  
Looking further into this, I realize there is a lot of work to be done 
to make this happen.  I think it is better to work on a simpler domain.  
I plan on adding a confinement of mozilla in FC7.  But right now an 
concentrating on RHEL 5/FC6
>  -- 
>  fedora-selinux-list mailing list
>  fedora-selinux-list(a)redhat.com
>  https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-selinux-list