On 3/15/21 10:45, Ben Cotton wrote:
On Mon, Mar 15, 2021 at 10:41 AM Brandon Nielsen
> Can we also add a "and displayed without error" clause, or maybe
> "completes with no visible error"? Something to explicitly capture the
> "sad face" bug.
>  - https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1924908
I thought about that and decided to leave it off as a Basic criterion.
I'd be fine with it for Final, but I was worried it would be too
strict for Beta, where we expect some degree of sad face from time to
time. But maybe this isn't one of those cases? If the consensus is to
include a "no errors!", I won't object.
A Beta is something that we release to the general public. I don't think
it's good for Fedora's reputation to have the Oops sad face screen show
up during the installation / setup.
Sure there will be bugs in a Beta. I and I think most folks expect to
see a small number of SE alerts and/or Abrt notifications, but not
something that Shouts "I'm Broken!"; especially during install / setup.
Perhaps a middle position would be to say the sad face screen can't be
Have a Great Day!