Greetings testers!
While looking into the affects of the yum/dnf migration I noticed some cleanup
opportunities with the release criteria and thought I'd email the list before
making any changes.
Beta
====
Package set selection
Should we update this to say "when using any network install image..."
instead of "when using the generic?" I'd add a note with something like,
"[Any?] This means any of the productized network installation media and
the base network installation image."
Kickstart Delivery
Not really a criterion change, but we still list a diskette as a supported
delivery mechanism [0]. Should we remove this, or do we still actively test
using a diskette for ks delivery?
Updgrade Requirements
This currently reads: "The release-blocking package sets are the minimal set,
and the sets for each one of the release-blocking desktops."
Should this be updated to "each one of the release-blocking products and
release-blocking desktops?"
Domain controller role
The note says this criteria should be removed after F21 - but since rolekit
relies on yum to install the bits needed for the domain controller, should
we keep this in place for F22 through the dnf migration?
Cloud-init
This was an oversight on my part originally. We need to define the specific
bits of cloud-init that need to work. It'd be nice and easy to just say,
"all of them," but cloud-init has a yum module and no dnf module. We need
to figure out what to do about cloud-init if dnf support won't be added.
Role installation
For at least F22, do we need to have a criterion for installing new roles
with rolekit? Or will "brought to a working configuration" cover this enough?
Final
=====
Domain controller role
As with the beta, I'd suggest we keep this through F22 to make sure things
work.
I know herding the Release Criteria is typically an Adam thing, but thought
I'd go ahead and ping the list with these small bits.
Thoughts?
[0]
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Anaconda/Kickstart#Chapter_6._Making_the_Ki...
--
// Mike
--
Fedora QA
freenode: roshi
http://roshi.fedorapeople.org