Tim:
I don't see why that's wrong, there were plenty of things that discover their hostname by doing a reverse look-up of their IP. And he demonstrated several releases that worked exactly that way.
Samuel Sieb:
What are these plenty of things? This is the first that I know of. And the question still remains. Is the OS looking up the hostname at runtime or was it always the installer setting it at install time?
He listed several, and even showed a demo.
I listed one Apache, and I seem to recall Jabber and Dovecot did the same thing (they don't ask your OS what it's host and domain name are, it checks via DNS lookups).