Trademark license agreement status
Robert 'Bob' Jensen
bob at fedoraunity.org
Tue Sep 8 17:42:02 UTC 2009
----- "Jeff Spaleta" <jspaleta at gmail.com> wrote:
> Unfortunately, I can't do much about inappropriate private comments
> that have been directed at you...or inappropriate private comments
> directed at anyone. How much of the heat in the public discussion is
> spill over from private communications where a line was crossed and
> someone got offended and there weren't others in the conversation to
> work on smooth over the discord? I don't know, but I'm guessing its a
> majority of it...for everybody who is showing a little fray around
> the
> edges on this issue. Another reason I personally appreciate the
> legal
> reps willingness to come out on the public list and have a
> discussion.
>
> I understand that you don't like having the TLA exist at all. I get
> it. I think we can all agree that legal issues blow monkey chunks.
> Legal issues which intersect community interests...even more so.
> I
> really wish there was a pre-existing copyleft approach to trademark
> that still allowed the trademark to be enforcible for a license. But
> I'm not aware of such a construction. As it stands right now we
> have
> to make a choice with regard to keeping the trademark in an
> enforceable state. I think Glezos summed up the underlying issue. Is
> protecting the trademark long term worth the intangible short term
> cost? Its a very difficult question. We seemed to have survived the
> introduction of the CLA for contributors even though there was heat
> when it was introduced.
>
It was pointed out that "fedorasucks.com" is available, I would never register it and I would expect that it be dealt with by Red Hat Legal. I know that the TLA or some other channel is needed for them to do so don't get me wrong. I hope that the issues will be worked out, I have faith at this time they will. I also hope it can be a model for other groups that are similar to the community we have.
-- Bob
More information about the advisory-board
mailing list