To semi-rolling or not to semi-rolling, that is the question...

[Kevin Kofler]

Doug Ledford wrote:
> You only need enough details to know that it isn't impossible, not
> enough to know the exact route to get to the end goal.

Only an actually working implementation, or a detailed technical description 
of one, can prove that it really isn't impossible and doesn't lead to 
unsurmountable technical difficulties that make it suck in practice.

> Please, if you have objections to the policy, then state them.  What I
> got from your email is you objected to me saying set policy first,
> technical implementation later, and then you never once said anything
> about the policy nor the technical implementation.  Should I then take
> your silence on those issues to mean that you are OK with the policy and
> OK with the proposed technical implementation?

I'm going to reply to your original message.

        Kevin Kofler