Summary/Minutes from today's Env-and-Stacks WG meeting (2014-02-18)

Deborah Rieden drieden at redhat.com
Mon Feb 24 16:20:59 UTC 2014


----- Original Message -----
> From: "Tadej Jane┼ż" <tadej.janez at tadej.hicsalta.si>
> To: env-and-stacks at lists.fedoraproject.org
> Sent: Wednesday, February 19, 2014 9:58:43 AM
> Subject: Re: Summary/Minutes from today's Env-and-Stacks WG meeting	(2014-02-18)
> 
> On Wed, 2014-02-19 at 12:56 +0100, Honza Horak wrote:
> > Just to sum it up, these are names proposed so far:
> > 
> > Ugly
> > Staging
> > Incubation
> > Easy
> > Playground
> > Mantle
> > Experimental
> > Unstable
> 
> Since we decided to start with a single repository that would implement
> an "ugly"-like repository, I would prefer not to use names like Staging,
> Incubation, since they hint at a different kind of repository that we
> might have in the future.
> 
> My preferences so far are:
> Playground > Easy > Experimental > Mantle
> 
> My argument for the Playground name is that we want to invite new
> contributors/packagers and let them play with Fedora, without requiring
> them to know all the intricacies of the current Fedora Packaging
> Guidelines (FPG). And afterwards, it is their choice:
> 1) Their packages can stay in the Playground repo forever (maybe because
> it would be very unpractical to meet the FPG, or they simply don't care
> enough to work on being FPG compliant)
> 2) Their packages would improve over-time and steadily become FPG
> compliant. At the end, they would just submit their package for a formal
> review and have it included in Fedora's main repo.
> 
> Looking at the name from the repo's consumers point-of-view, it would
> indicate them that things here are "young by heart". Some packages may
> be quite rough, while others might be more mature and closer to being
> FPG compliant. Of course, like in real life, some packages will always
> remain "young by heart".

I like the reasoning that you have presented.

My highest preference is for playground.  In addition to what Tadej has
written I think "playground" conveys a sense of space and openness.  
In a playground there are some rules, everyone can join and play in the playground.

Some of the other terms have a negative connotation: unstable, experimental, incubation, ugly.

Staging implies that there has been some work and is in a good state.  This seems
to indicate that things are farther along than in a playground.

Easy seems vague to me.  But it does sound inviting.
Mantle initially conjures images of a fireplace.

Debi


> 
> Tadej
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> env-and-stacks mailing list
> env-and-stacks at lists.fedoraproject.org
> https://lists.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/env-and-stacks
> 

-- 
Debi Rieden
Engineering Program Manager
(Developer Toolset (DTS), Software Collections (RHSCL), LPC Pilot and some other projects), Fedora Environment and Stacks Working Group
Westford (2S719)
Office: 978-392-1023; Cell 617-669-2934
drieden at redhat.com
#devtoolset, #boston, #software-collections, #fedora-stacks


More information about the env-and-stacks mailing list