Email Addresses (Revisited)

seth vidal skvidal at
Mon Apr 9 14:03:07 UTC 2007

On Mon, 2007-04-09 at 08:58 -0500, Mike McGrath wrote:
> So this thread kind of got forgotten about without any action.  Here's 
> where it left off.
> current situation:
> User signs up and gets account at fp.o and firstname.lastname at fp.o
> The problem:
> accounts are unique but firstname.lastname is not.  This causes 
> collisions. 
> Firstname.Lastname may (and currently does) contain characters that 
> postfix and sendmail freak out about.
> Secondary problem:
> People think firstname.lastname sounds professional while 
> accountname at fp.o may not.
> I'd like to move forward with removing the firstname.lastname addresses 
> after sending out a notification.  Secondary issues aside, our current 
> model can't work forever and already causes some issues.
> Are there any major detractors?

I think it's a good plan - we should be willing to keep a couple of
fname.lname aliases for some folks who have already published them/used
them elsewhere. And we should say as much in the warning email.

but by and large I think killing them will be fine.


More information about the infrastructure mailing list