[Fedora-packaging] create a wrapper installer
Garrett Holmstrom
gholms at fedoraproject.org
Thu May 6 01:13:41 UTC 2010
On 5/5/2010 18:04, MGandra at diskeeper.com wrote:
> I have an rpm package for installation. Before I install I should
> display the License Agreement and when the user accepts it then I should
> install the package. I know we don’t have user interaction in rpm, what
> I am looking at is how to create an wrapper so that I can present this
> license agreement and then ask the user to agree it and if he says “Yes”
> or “y” I can continue to install.
>
> I have seen programs like“jdk-6u18-linux-i586-rpm.bin” and other which are able to do this. We will just change the file to exectable and then run it.
We've found this problematic in the past at my workplace. In
particular, it makes the product very difficult to automatically install
or update since customers never get their hands on the actual binary
RPMs. This forces sysadmins to log into every machine individually
every time they want to install or update the program just so the
installer can display some license agreement they've already read and
agreed to. This is especially important to corporate customers who
don't care to spend their time doing this for a network of hundreds of
machines. If you insist on using a wrapper, please make it possible to
extract the binary RPM so customers can add it to their private package
management systems and avoid this mess.
As a simple alternative, I suggest sending customers to a web page with
the license agreement that they can accept before actually downloading
product RPMs. This makes it easier both for packagers like yourself as
well as for customers who want to roll out products to a number of
computers. Sun, Oracle, and VMware all do this sort of thing with many
of their products since there's no point in making somebody accept the
same license agreement hundreds of times.
More information about the packaging
mailing list