debian at herakles.homelinux.org
Sun May 24 09:58:43 UTC 2009
Kevin Kofler wrote:
> Allen Kistler wrote:
>> All the release criteria on the referenced page are about booting and
>> running, which makes sense as far as it goes, but what about shutting
>> down? Although they're mostly fixed now, there was a series of bugs
>> dealing with F11 being unable under certain conditions to shut down
>> without the use of the power button.
> You can always hit the power button if the system fails to shutdown, so it
> isn't really critical.
Are you sane?
I the system won't shut down properly, a quick press of the power button
is likely not to work either.
Hitting the power button to force a poweroff risks loss of data. It is
most certainly _not_ fit for release if this is expected.
> The idea is that everything which can be fixed in an update is not
Are there any criteria that said, "Must not harm anyone's computer?" I
raise this because, a while ago, there was a kernel bug that could harm
computers (including the HP DC7700) that had on-board Intel NICs.
Fedora stepped around that one by disabling the offending driver, but
there still existed a risk for those who might build their own kernels.
Opensuse released an alpha, beta or preview or some such containing this
bug. The release notes mentioned it, but I thought it incredibly risky.
1aaaaaaa at coco.merseine.nu Z1aaaaaaa at coco.merseine.nu
You cannot reply off-list:-)
More information about the test