Proven Tester documentation

John Dulaney j_dulaney at
Mon Jun 28 22:12:26 UTC 2010

During the meeting today it was decided to combine the Proven Tester and Join Proven Tester documentation.  I haven't changed much:

The Proven Testers are a dedicated group of the [[QA|Fedora Quality Assurance]] Community who work towards making sure packages in the [[Critical_Path_Packages|Critical Path]] are not broken in [[Releases/Branched|Fedora Branched]] as well as [[Releases|Fedora Stable]]. They retrieve their updates from the [[updates-testing]] repository and report their findings as karma using [[Bodhi]]. Positive karma from a proven tester is required for each critical path update before it can be pushed to the stable repository.
A proven tester is a member of the [ proventesters] group. Individuals who wish to join this group must first be mentored and approved. 
== Testing Updates ==Proven testers verify a basic level of stability before releasing an update to the public. They do not need to test for total correctness or ensure complete test coverage. Some tests will vary depending on the type of the package, while others must pass for all updates. Generally speaking, an update should successfully execute all applicable [[critical path action]]s. The [[Fedora release criteria]] is another useful guide for minimum testing criteria.
Proven testers verify updates by installing them from the updates-testing repository. To ensure rapid detection of regressions, a full system update from this repository should be performed at least once a day. Individual packages may be updated more quickly if the need for verification is urgent.
=== General Tests ===# The system must be able to shut down and reboot.# The user must be able to log in to the desktop.# The user must be able to access the network.
=== Testing Applications ===If the package is an application, run the application and check that basic operations work. 
=== Testing Libraries and Shared Components ===If it is a library or other shared component, run an application which uses the component and ensure that that works.
== Feedback Procedures ==Since a proven tester's karma determines whether an update is allowed to be promoted, they follow special procedures based on the severity of regressions they encounter. Use {{package|fedora-easy-karma}} to list all installed packages from the updates-testing repository and allow to file feedback on each one at a time. Pay particular attention to updates whose description notes that they are critical path updates. 
=== Major bugs ===If you identified any serious problems in earlier testing and were able to identify the package responsible, post negative feedback for that package. If possible, please file a bug report on the problem and link to the bug report in your feedback message. A good feedback message quickly and clearly identifies the behavior change and the cause, if you were able to determine it.
=== Minor bugs ===If you identify a problem which is minor in nature and does not impede the actual critical path functionality, please do not post negative feedback. Post neutral or positive feedback with a note of the issue encountered (and a link to a bug report if appropriate).
=== Previously reported bugs ===If your testing uncovers no problems but you see that another tester has identified a serious problem with the package, please try to replicate their problem, and post negative feedback if you are now able to confirm it. If you are not able to confirm the problem but you suspect this may be because you cannot recreate the necessary conditions, please post neutral feedback noting that you were unable to duplicate the problem. Only post positive feedback if you are sure your testing indicates the other reporter's negative feedback is a mistake.
=== Unfamiliar packages ===If you are not sure what the component does or how to test it, do not post positive or negative feedback. If the above general tests of booting, network functionality and update functionality identified no problems, it is fine to leave a neutral feedback message noting that you were able to boot the system and perform critical path tasks with the update installed.
== How to Join ==
The following steps are imperative to join the QA Proven Testers:
{||- style="color: white; background-color: #3074c2; font-weight: bold" align="aligned" |'''Step'''||'''Task'''||'''Details'''|-|1 || Sign up for the [ Fedora Account System]. || You must have a FAS account before you participate here.|-|2 || Pick a Mentor!|| As the interested QA Community member, it is your responsibility to request a mentor from the [ Fedora QA Trac] instance by filing a new ticket. |-|3 || Apply for Proven Testers|| Details of the procedure to apply for the Proven Testers QA group are below.|-
Once these steps are complete and your mentor confirms you have demonstrated an understanding of QA process and community, your application for approval to the Critical Path Wranglers (Proven Testers) will be brought up for review with the current Critical Path Wranglers (Proven Testers). Once approved by the Critical Path Wranglers, you will be able to apply for, and be approved for, the [ ProvenTesters group] within [ FAS.]
The [ ProvenTesters group] within [ FAS] will grant the ability to add what is known as "weighted" karma inside of [ Bodhi] to the [[Critical_Path_Packages|Critical Path]] packages within Fedora [ Fedora Branched]. Karma that is "weighted" is known as such because each package that requires it must have, at minimum, a quota of weighted karma in addition to karma added by all other QA Community members. This means that everyone can offer up karma to the packages within [[Critical_Path_Packages|Critical Path]] but a certain number of Proven Testers karma is required for that package to be approved as stable.
== Proven Testers Mentor Candidates ==A Mentor candidate is any current Proven Tester. An interested QA Community Member who would like to become sponsored may request a current Proven Tester as their Mentor as part of their trac ticket if they have a preference of who mentors them. Once the candidate Mentor accepts the interested QA Community Member's request this Mentor will oversee the interested member and help them work within the Critical Path QA efforts, policies, and procedures.
== External Links ==* [ Bodhi]* [ Bugzilla]

<all>John Henry DulaneyVolunteer and Docent, North Carolina Maritime Museum 		 	   		  
The New Busy think 9 to 5 is a cute idea. Combine multiple calendars with Hotmail.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...

More information about the test mailing list