will F18 allow simultaneous installation of more than one desktop?

"Jóhann B. Guðmundsson" johannbg at gmail.com
Sat Jul 7 09:15:33 UTC 2012


On 07/06/2012 07:10 PM, Andre Robatino wrote:
> I attempted installation using Fedora-20120703-x86_64-916dfe7-netinst.iso and
> found that it only allows choosing one desktop. I normally install both Gnome
> and KDE at this point and asked about it on #anaconda. Dlehman it was not
> planned to support that, and regarding installing other desktops afterwards and
> choosing between them at the login prompt, he said that wasn't up to them, but
> personally he frowned on that practice.

I agree with David the installer should not support that and also frown 
upon that practice.

I also think that once the novice end user has choose in his DE in the 
installer he should only be presented with packages/applications 
targeted specifically for that desktop environment if he should be 
presented with options to install additional packages et al...

> If it's not possible to have more than one desktop installed, it makes changing
> desktops much harder (clean install?) and someone who doesn't like Gnome Shell,
> for example, may well decide to change distros rather than try a different
> desktop. Personally, I use Gnome, but install KDE just to have the KDE packages
> available while using Gnome. Would this become impossible?
>

I dont think this argument holds much water.

Novice end users would be more likely to download an alternative ( 
encase of an live cd/usb ) from the same distribution and try it out 
since they are already familiar with the the process of downloading and 
( or re)installing the OS and experience users that want to run multiple 
DE's can already install another one once they have successfully 
finished installing the distribution.

JBG


More information about the test mailing list