Install question #2 - disk order and video mode

Bill Davidsen davidsen at tmr.com
Wed Mar 12 23:29:41 UTC 2008


Chris Snook wrote:
> Bill Davidsen wrote:
>> The FC8 install seems to assign drive identifiers in some random order 
>> instead of BIOS order. I thought that was fixed back around 2.6.17, 
>> but it certainly isn't the case AFAIK, if I boot the rescue CD I get 
>> one set of assignments (not BIOS order), and if I boot I get another. 
>> Needless to say this makes getting a bootable install nearly impossible.
> 
> Device scanning is asynchronous now, and drives may come up in *any* 
> order, potentially changing even across reboots even with no changes to 
> software or hardware.  This is why we use labels and uuids.
> 
I see nothing in the description of grub.conf which indicates that these 
can be used, it seems to want things like (hd3,0) and similar. The 
problem I'm hitting is that the associated drive "3,0" is not the same 
drive on every boot. It is either the PATA drive on the primary of the 
first motherboard controller, OR the primary of the first controller on 
the PCI Promise controller. At least once in 25-30 boots the partition 
type was a5 (FreeBSD) which means it was on the VIA RAID controller 
(JBOD mode) in the pluggable drive bay.

If there's some trick to getting grub to look at lebals or uuid I am 
missing it.

-- 
Bill Davidsen <davidsen at tmr.com>
   "We have more to fear from the bungling of the incompetent than from
the machinations of the wicked."  - from Slashdot




More information about the users mailing list