Installation plays hardball

R. G. Newbury newbury at mandamus.org
Sat Jan 2 23:36:27 UTC 2010


On Sat, 02 Jan 2010 20:10:37 +1030, Tim wrote

 >It makes almost no sense to use it on laptops, where you can only have 
 > single drive (adding an outboard drive is quite impractical, you'd end
 > up with a box of bits all cabled together).  And you face the
 > difficulty of finding recovery tools for LVM (I haven't seen any) for
 > any repair jobs, but there are widely written about tools for 
rescuing > data from ext3 partitions.

 >The only advantage I found for using LVM on my laptop was encryption. 
  > I could have the encompassing LVM volume encrypted, and as many
 > partitions as I liked, and only have to unlock the outer container.
 > Using various ext3 partitions, I had to type in the password numerous 
 > times to boot up the computer.

 > If you're the sort that uses one huge partition for everything (and
 > that does seem to be the recommendation, these days), *and* you never 
 > intend to add a second drive, then LVM is pointless to you.

ONE HUGE PARTITION?  I'd like to know who is crazy enough to recommend 
that, because I would want to stay well away from him. That's *almost* 
as bad as win(spit!).

I always set up my boxen with separate partitions for /boot, /home, 
/tmp, /var and /.
And /var/lib/mysql is a symlink into /home/misc, as is /var/www/html. 
That way if /tmp or /var ever fill from error messages, it is simple to 
clean up and get running again. Also, with /home as a separate 
partition, it is dead simple to install again, or install a new version 
or distro without destroying all your data.
Most installs seem to want to over-write /var too, even if/when you say 
'Don't format', which is why /var/lib/mysql and /var/www/html are 
symlinked elsewhere. (You *DO* want to lose your Nolapro accounting 
setup and accounting data too in one swell foop?).

On this desktop I also have a partition for /usr/local, for all my *own* 
programs and scripts.
Geoff




-- 
         Please let me know if anything I say offends you.
          I may wish to offend you again in the future.

          Tux says: "Be regular. Eat cron flakes."




More information about the users mailing list