[Fedora-directory-users] what's wrong with this ACI?

[speedy zinc]

I've created two user entries under People:

Test User: uid=testuser
Jane Doe : uid=JDoe

Here's what I'm trying to achieve with access control:

- Turn off anon access to the entry Test User
- Allow full access to Test User on Test User
- Allow (read, search, compare) to JDoe on Test User,
and
no other users
- Allow full access to "cn=Directory Manager" on Test 
User.
- Anon access is still allowed on other entries

So, here is the list of ACIs (besides the inherited
ones)
that I've created on the entry Test User:

(targetattr = "*") (version 3.0;acl "self";allow
(all)(userdn = "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,
dc=dummy,dc=com");)

(targetattr != "userPassword") (version 3.0;acl "No
anonymous access";deny (all)(userdn =
"ldap:///anyone");)

(targetattr = "*") (target =
"ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People, dc=dummy,dc=com")
(version 3.0;acl "Allow JDoe";allow
(read,compare,search)(userdn =
"ldap:///uid=JDoe,ou=People, dc=dummy,dc=com");)

With the ACIs above, it seems that the "No anonymous
access"
is taking precendence over the other two. Even the
"Test 
User" does not have access to its own data, and JDoe 
certainly does not either. The only user who has
access 
is the Directory Manager.

How do I achieve my goals with ACI?

thanks a lot.

sz.



	
		
__________________________________ 
Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 
http://mail.yahoo.com

[Chen Shaopeng]

speedy zinc wrote:
>  I've created two user entries under People:
>  
>  Test User: uid=testuser
>  Jane Doe : uid=JDoe
>  
>  Here's what I'm trying to achieve with access control:
>  
>  - Turn off anon access to the entry Test User
>  - Allow full access to Test User on Test User
>  - Allow (read, search, compare) to JDoe on Test User,
>  and
>  no other users
>  - Allow full access to "cn=Directory Manager" on Test 
>  User.
>  - Anon access is still allowed on other entries
>  
>  So, here is the list of ACIs (besides the inherited
>  ones)
>  that I've created on the entry Test User:
>  
>  (targetattr = "*") (version 3.0;acl "self";allow
>  (all)(userdn = "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,
>  dc=dummy,dc=com");)
>  
>  (targetattr != "userPassword") (version 3.0;acl "No
>  anonymous access";deny (all)(userdn =
>  "ldap:///anyone");)
>  
>  (targetattr = "*") (target =
>  "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People, dc=dummy,dc=com")
>  (version 3.0;acl "Allow JDoe";allow
>  (read,compare,search)(userdn =
>  "ldap:///uid=JDoe,ou=People, dc=dummy,dc=com");)
>  
>  With the ACIs above, it seems that the "No anonymous
>  access"
>  is taking precendence over the other two. Even the
>  "Test 
>  User" does not have access to its own data, and JDoe 
>  certainly does not either. The only user who has
>  access 
>  is the Directory Manager.
>  
>  How do I achieve my goals with ACI?
>   
Note that ACIs are logically ORed during evaluation. And "deny"
always takes precedence over "allow". So, your ACI
which [deny(all)(userdn="ldap:///anyone")] will take precendence
over the other two. Therefore, even Test User is denied reading
his own data.

You can combine the 3 ACIs above into the following:

(targetattr="*")(target="ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,dc=dummy,dc=com")
(version 3.0;acl "Self and JDoe (but no anon to all)";
deny(all)(userdn != "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,dc=dummy,dc=com ||
ldap://uid=JDoe,ou=People,dc=dummy,dc=com");)

This tells the server to deny to all on that specific target except
if userdn is "testuser" or "JDoe" .

Hope that helps.

csp
-- 
Chen Shaopeng
http://www.idsignet.com

[speedy zinc]

--- Chen Shaopeng <chen_shaopeng(a)idsignet.com&gt; wrote:

>  
>  Note that ACIs are logically ORed during evaluation.
>  And "deny"
>  always takes precedence over "allow". So, your ACI
>  which [deny(all)(userdn="ldap:///anyone")] will take
>  precendence
>  over the other two. Therefore, even Test User is
>  denied reading
>  his own data.
>  
>  You can combine the 3 ACIs above into the following:
>  
(targetattr="*")(target="ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,dc=dummy,dc=com")
>  (version 3.0;acl "Self and JDoe (but no anon to
>  all)";
>  deny(all)(userdn !=
>  "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,dc=dummy,dc=com ||
>  ldap://uid=JDoe,ou=People,dc=dummy,dc=com");)
>  
>  This tells the server to deny to all on that
>  specific target except
>  if userdn is "testuser" or "JDoe" .
>  
>  Hope that helps.
>   
Thanks a lot, Chen! Exactly what I want :)

sz



		
__________________________________ 
Yahoo! FareChase: Search multiple travel sites in one click.
http://farechase.yahoo.com

[Rich Megginson]

Another thing to remember about ACIs is that everything is denied by 
default.  The only things that are allowed are those things which you 
explicitly allow.  So you don't usually have to create deny rules.

speedy zinc wrote:

> I've created two user entries under People:
>
> Test User: uid=testuser
> Jane Doe : uid=JDoe
>
> Here's what I'm trying to achieve with access control:
>
> - Turn off anon access to the entry Test User
> - Allow full access to Test User on Test User
> - Allow (read, search, compare) to JDoe on Test User,
> and
> no other users
> - Allow full access to "cn=Directory Manager" on Test 
> User.
> - Anon access is still allowed on other entries
>
> So, here is the list of ACIs (besides the inherited
> ones)
> that I've created on the entry Test User:
>
> (targetattr = "*") (version 3.0;acl "self";allow
> (all)(userdn = "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People,
> dc=dummy,dc=com");)
>
> (targetattr != "userPassword") (version 3.0;acl "No
> anonymous access";deny (all)(userdn =
> "ldap:///anyone");)
>
> (targetattr = "*") (target =
> "ldap:///uid=testuser,ou=People, dc=dummy,dc=com")
> (version 3.0;acl "Allow JDoe";allow
> (read,compare,search)(userdn =
> "ldap:///uid=JDoe,ou=People, dc=dummy,dc=com");)
>
> With the ACIs above, it seems that the "No anonymous
> access"
> is taking precendence over the other two. Even the
> "Test 
> User" does not have access to its own data, and JDoe 
> certainly does not either. The only user who has
> access 
> is the Directory Manager.
>
> How do I achieve my goals with ACI?
>
> thanks a lot.
>
> sz.
>
>
>
> 	
> 		
> __________________________________ 
> Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005 
> http://mail.yahoo.com
>
> --
> Fedora-directory-users mailing list
> Fedora-directory-users(a)redhat.com
> https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/fedora-directory-users
>   
>