git branch help?
Kevin Kofler
kevin.kofler at chello.at
Tue Aug 3 04:41:22 UTC 2010
Matt McCutchen wrote:
> Are you comparing git to Mercurial or to a centralized VCS?
Both. Git is just a PITA in its own league, but DVCSes as a whole are a
broken (*) and unhelpful (inherently hard to use) concept.
(*) e.g. because of the strong reliance on hashes, which can make the whole
thing break down in the event of a hash collision, and which make commit IDs
nonsequential and unpredictable
> Some of the complexity is intrinsic to distributed VCS and has to be
> weighed against the significant benefits to people who build custom
> packages, like me.
I don't see how dist-git makes it any easier to build customized packages.
If you really want a local git mirror of a centralized repository, you can
also use git-cvs, git-svn or the like. For SVN, SVK is also a nice solution.
All this dist-git migration has brought us is chaos, a much higher barrier
to entry and much harder work for existing packagers. (And yes, I've also
tried to make these points BEFORE the migration, but nobody listened.)
Kevin Kofler
More information about the devel
mailing list