Dne Čt 28. června 2012 12:11:02, Jóhann B. Guðmundsson napsal(a):
On Thu, Jun 28, 2012 at 10:45 AM, Karel Volný
kvolny@redhat.com wrote:
I simply don't like this idea, there is enough bugzilla noise and enough bureaucracy (read: obstacles) for anyone wanting to contribute (yes, even just clicking +1/-1 karma is a valuable contribution ...)
This is no additional bureocrasy thou you claim it to be
please elaborate on this
situation now: step 1. follow a link to bodhi step 2. click "Add a comment" (optional) step 3. write a comment what doesn't work for you step 4. click "does not work" step 5. click "Add Comment"
your proposal: step 1. follow a link to bodhi step 2. click "Add a comment" step 3. open Bugzilla in another window step 4. click New steps 5.-96. do all the things you have to do to properly file a bug step 97. return to bodhi step 98. write a comment which includes the newly reported bug number step 99. "click does not work" step 100. click "Add Comment"
you really don't see anything additional in the second case?
and please do sell/explain it further what value you see in having reporters to just click +1/-1
I see whether someone actually bothered to test the update, and what is the result
Btw way please follow [1]
http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines#Proper_po sting_style
it was directed to a topic as a whole, not to a specific paragraph of your text ... sorry for not removing the original message not to "increase the size of the daily digests" but I'd find it more "highly confusing and incoherent" if I'd just deleted it
btw, please follow http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines#Be_Courteous (or is it just me who finds it at least a bit strange to start the thread by ill-founded, as Adam pointed out, attack on FESCO?)
K.