Comments/ Feedback on Students proposals

[Buddhike Kurera]

Hello mentors and contributors,

We are getting good number of proposal submissions now. Since the
deadline is getting closer the number will keep
increasing I suppose. The deadline for proposal submission is 6th
April, 1900 UTC.

Though proposals are submitted via google-melange a copy of the
proposal is included on the wiki as well.
Therefore mentors can use google-melange to add their comments and
others can add comments on
the proposals talk page. Mentor also can post their comment on the
google-melange to the proposals talk page,
if they wish.

Your comments will help the students to make their proposals smarter.

Mentors can start giving scores on proposals. But I think it is better
to wait till you get all the proposals
for the idea and then start giving marks.

There is no hard rule and always we are open for ideas, so please feel
free to discuss any idea or concern.
Thanks for the support.

[Buddhike Kurera]

On Tue, Apr 3, 2012 at 11:06 PM, Buddhike Kurera
 wrote:
> Hello mentors and contributors,
>
> We are getting good number of proposal submissions now. Since the
> deadline is getting closer the number will keep
> increasing I suppose. The deadline for proposal submission is 6th
> April, 1900 UTC.
>
> Though proposals are submitted via google-melange a copy of the
> proposal is included on the wiki as well.
> Therefore mentors can use google-melange to add their comments and
> others can add comments on
> the proposals talk page. Mentor also can post their comment on the
> google-melange to the proposals talk page,
> if they wish.

Mentors:

Just FYI,

Please make sure to uncheck "Private" box, below the comment box on
the students' proposal page,
if you wish to make your comment visible to student.

If your comment is only for admins and/or mentors please make sure the
box is checked.

[Mo Morsi]

On 04/03/2012 01:36 PM, Buddhike Kurera wrote:
> Hello mentors and contributors,
>
> We are getting good number of proposal submissions now. Since the
> deadline is getting closer the number will keep
> increasing I suppose. The deadline for proposal submission is 6th
> April, 1900 UTC.
>
> Though proposals are submitted via google-melange a copy of the
> proposal is included on the wiki as well.
> Therefore mentors can use google-melange to add their comments and
> others can add comments on
> the proposals talk page. Mentor also can post their comment on the
> google-melange to the proposals talk page,
> if they wish.
>
> Your comments will help the students to make their proposals smarter.
>
> Mentors can start giving scores on proposals. But I think it is better
> to wait till you get all the proposals
> for the idea and then start giving marks.
>
> There is no hard rule and always we are open for ideas, so please feel
> free to discuss any idea or concern.
> Thanks for the support.

Hey quick question, was wondering how the post-application approval
process works. Is it completely up to google which proposal get
accepted? Do we (fedora-summer-coding) have any input into that process?

Thanks alot,
    -Mo