On 9/29/22 09:37, Michael Catanzaro wrote:
On Thu, Sep 29 2022 at 08:12:10 AM -0000, James bond
<prabesh432(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> I mean, what's next?
> - Remove all torrent software, because it can be used to download...
> Juridiction=IANAL, Possibility
> - Use LibreKernel because... Juridiction = IANAL, Possibility
> - ...
The difference is Fedora Legal is OK with torrent software and Linux
firmware, but not OK with unapproved multimedia codecs. There's no
point in trying to debate this on a public mailing list as the lawyers
who make these decisions don't read the list.
I'm confident that Fedora Legal wants to allow as much as possible
because they have worked with us on this in the past, which is why
today Fedora is able to play MP3, AAC, and even H.264 (via OpenH264)
when all three of these technologies were totally banned just a few
years ago. In Fedora 38, we'll have a new service,
fedora-autofirstboot, that installs OpenH264 for you with no user
interaction, so soon users will be able to play most MP4s
out-of-the-box with zero manual intervention required to make it work.
(This is already ready, just not enabled yet in F37.) I expect our
multimedia situation to improve even more in the future because I
suspect there is a little more we can do here. But when Fedora Legal
says we cannot do something, they really mean it and we have to respect
that.
Could OpenH264 be hooked up to hardware acceleration somehow?
--
Sincerely,
Demi Marie Obenour (she/her/hers)