Please do not reply directly to this email. All additional
comments should be made in the comments box of this bug.
--- Comment #4 from Zach Oglesby <oglesbyzm(a)gmail.com> 2011-05-04 10:29:32 EDT ---
(In reply to comment #2)
A couple of things strike me. We've had the SELinux guide, the
guide, amateur radio guide, etc - all of which could be on either side of
'something that can be done with Fedora' and 'how to use Fedora'.
We've always been pretty accepting of documents, and I don't see any reason to
not be with this one. I'd want to see the canonical DocBook source repo moved
to the docs/ tree on fedorahhosted.org
All of that said, the current state of the document also (IMO) has unacceptable
content for publication on docs.fedoraproject.org
- it advocates installation
space, (in reviewing Eric's test in that regard it stops
being how to use Fedora (Fedora being defined as the packages available in
Fedora) and moves to something that can be done with Fedora.) The document
should only talk about what can be done with Fedora, not what can be done with
packages external to Fedora. (adhering to this standard keeps us from running
afoul of trademark usage guidelines IMO as well). In other words make sure
this is Fedora documentation about using FreeIPA, not FreeIPA documentation
using Fedora as the base OS. Note that I am not advocating stripping the
sections on Solaris and other operating systems, but think the focus should
remain on Fedora as the 'server' and non-Fedora OSes as clients. Also this
document also doesn't appear to be using the full Fedora publican brand - as
the feedback section contains comments about filing bugs against RHEL, etc.
I think this could not be said better, we have lots of guides that help people
do things with Fedora, but they rely strictly on Fedora. As long as the guide
keeps within the realm of the "Official Fedora" world, and its helpful to a
group of people (like the Amateur Radio Guide) then I would love to include it.
Configure bugmail: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the QA contact for the bug.