On Tue, Jul 26, 2011 at 12:33, Abi R <nightmoves(a)fedoraproject.org> wrote:
Come to think of it, you guys should prolly go with kemter's idea. Buddhika
is too busy to color it and nobody else wishes to or if you do, go right
ahead. I think I'm done with the task.
so i'd like to apologize. I mistook the tone of the above e-mail and
initiated a sidelined conversation with Abi. After the intial e-mail
I should have brought it back into the thread, but hitting reply is
just too easy/lazy. that is my fault.
the summary (i can provide the thread if anyone feels it is needed) was this:
i said I liked where kemter went with the logo as far as the favicon
goes. it fits much more simply and is easier to scale. I did go onto
irc and chat with shenson, and he is a fan of the vintage (which I
like, but was worried about scale on). however that with with Abi's
explanations about his intent, we feel that it was a very nice concept
to try and go for a more complete "larger" logo with the vintage style
Abi was going aiming at for uses like the homepage and web app. I
suggested that maybe if the boot from the larger logo was a separate
layer in the final result and that layer could be scaled down to
provide the favicon.
so... like i said. my fault. I do like the favicon target of what
kemter colored, but was trying to see if there was a more in between
compromise that utilized Abi's artistic intent.
-greg/xaeth